Survey on Intelligent Wargaming: Tactical & Campaign Wargame and Strategic Game from Game-Theoretic Perspective

doi:10.16182/j.issn1004731x.joss.23-0300

Abstract

Abstract:

Wargaming is a pre-practice activity to study national security and competition, military conflict and war, crisis management, and other major strategic issues. An intelligent wargaming system needs the ability of artificial intelligence technology. This paper briefly summarizes the research progress of intelligent game, the evolution of wargaming, intelligent wargaming, and strategic gaming methods. From the perspective of game theory, it analyzes the game problem model for intelligent wargaming and sorts out the application mode of intelligent wargaming and the organization mode of a strategic game. An intelligent wargaming service-oriented architecture based on cloud native is proposed. Pre-training method for future decision-making cloud is explored for distributed confrontation at cloud edge, and a meta-game analysis framework for strategic wargaming is constructed for cognition of crisis events. It is expected to provide a scientific and effective reference for the research on the theory and tools of intelligent wargaming and offer theoretical and technical support for the new generation of intelligent cloud-edge cooperative command and control.

Key words: wargaming, strategic game, meta-game, conflict analysis, confrontation analysis, cloud native, pre-training

CLC Number:

TP391

Luo Junren, Zhang Wanpeng, Xiang Fengtao, Jiang Chaoyuan, Chen Jing. Survey on Intelligent Wargaming: Tactical & Campaign Wargame and Strategic Game from Game-Theoretic Perspective[J]. Journal of System Simulation, 2023, 35(9): 1871-1894.

Figures/Tables 18

Fig. 1

Fig. 2

Fig. 3

Table 1

Table 2

Fig. 4

Fig. 5

Table 3

Fig. 6

Fig. 7

Fig. 8

Fig. 9

Fig. 10

Fig. 11

Fig. 12

Fig. 13

Fig. 14

Fig. 15

References 117

1	Schechter B, Schneider J, Shaffer R. Wargaming as a Methodology: the International Crisis Wargame and Experimental Wargaming[J]. Simulation & Gaming, 2021, 52(4): 513-526.
2	高凯, 赵林. "混合战争"——俄罗斯新战略博弈手段[J]. 军事文摘, 2019(13): 10-13.
3	Silver D, Schrittwieser J, Simonyan K, et al. Mastering the Game of Go Without Human Knowledge[J]. Nature, 2017, 550(7676): 354-359.
4	OpenAI. Introducing ChatGPT[EB/OL]. [2023-03-02]. .
5	Meta Fundamental AI Research Diplomacy Team (FAIR), Bakhtin A, Brown N, et al. Human-level Play in the Game of Diplomacy by Combining Language Models with Strategic Reasoning[J]. Science, 2022, 378(6624): 1067-1074.
6	Kramár János, Eccles T, Gemp I, et al. Negotiation and Honesty in Artificial Intelligence Methods for the Board Game of Diplomacy[J]. Nature Communications, 2022, 13(1): 7214.
7	Perolat J, Bart De Vylder, Hennes D, et al. Mastering the Game of Stratego with Model-free Multiagent Reinforcement Learning[J]. Science, 2022, 378(6623): 990-996.
8	Anon. Constructive Machine-learning Battles with Adversary Tactics (COMBAT) [EB/OL]. (2021-12-14) [2022-09-01]. .
9	Waterman S. AFRL's 'Fight Tonight' to Prototype AI and Gaming Tech for Attack Planning[EB/OL]. (2021-12-14) [2022-09-01]. .
10	David R, LaPlante W. Final Report of the Defense Science Board (DSB) Task Force on Gaming, Exercising, Modeling, and Simulation. Executive Summary[R]. Washington, DC: Defense Science Board, 2021: 1-9.
11	TechConnect Defense. DARPA SCEPTER Program will Explore Machine-generated Strategies for Warfare[EB/OL]. (2022-01-24) [2022-08-29]. .
12	DARPA. SHADE: Stabilizing Hostilities Through Arbitration and Diplomatic Engagement[EB/OL]. (2022-06-30) [2023-06-29]. .
13	王志闻. 兵棋推演演变[M]. 北京: 国防大学出版社, 2020.
14	齐胜利. 战略推演论[M]. 北京: 国防大学出版社, 2020.
15	Clark B, Patt D, Schramm H. Mosaic Warfare: Exploiting Artificial Intelligence and Autonomous Systems to Implement Decision-Centric Operations[EB/OL]. (2020-02-11) [2022-08-29]. .
16	Spencer D K, Duncan S, Taliaferro A. Operationalizing Artificial Intelligence for Multi-domain Operations: a first look[C]//Artificial Intelligence and Machine Learning for Multi-domain Operations Applications. [S.I.]: SPIE, 2019: 1100602.
17	Oriesek D F, Schwarz J O. Winning the Uncertainty Game: Turning Strategic Intent into Results with Wargaming[M]. London: Routledge, 2020.
18	Evensen P I, Martinussen S E, Halsør M, et al. Wargaming Evolved: Methodology and Best Practices for Simulation-supported Wargaming[C]//The Interservice/Industry Training, Simulation & Education Conference (I/ITSEC). Orlando, FL (USA): The National Training and Simulation Association (NTSA), 2019: 19182.
19	刘海洋, 唐宇波, 胡晓峰, 等. 面向联合作战评估的兵棋推演实验研究[J]. 指挥与控制学报, 2018, 4(4): 272-280.
	Liu Haiyang, Tang Yubo, Hu Xiaofeng, et al. Wargaming Experiment Oriented Evaluation of Joint Operations[J]. Journal of Command and Control, 2018, 4(4): 272-280.
20	曹占广, 陶帅, 胡晓峰, 等. 国外兵棋推演及系统研究进展[J]. 系统仿真学报, 2021, 33(9): 2059-2065.
	Cao Zhanguang, Tao Shuai, Hu Xiaofeng, et al. Abroad Wargaming Deduction and System Research[J]. Journal of System Simulation, 2021, 33(9): 2059-2065.
21	Powell A L S. Wargaming All Domain Operations and Leader Development[R]. Fort Leavenworth, KS: School of Advanced Military Studies US Army Command and General Staff College, 2021: 1-49.
22	Frank A B, Bartels E M. Adaptive Engagement for Undergoverned Spaces: Concepts, Challenges, and Prospects for New Approaches[M]. Santa Monica, CA, USA: RAND Corporation, 2022.
23	NATO. NATO Analytical War Gaming-innovative Approaches for Data Capture, Analysis and Exploitation[EB/OL]. [2023-03-02]. $$TR-SAS-139-ALL.pdf.
24	尹奇跃, 赵美静, 倪晚成, 等. 兵棋推演的智能决策技术与挑战[J]. 自动化学报, 2023, 49(5): 913-928.
	Yin Qiyue, Zhao Meijing, Ni Wancheng, et al. Intelligent Decision Making Technology and Challenge of Wargame[J]. Acta Automatica Sinica, 2023, 49(5): 913-928.
25	贺筱媛, 郭圣明, 吴琳, 等. 面向智能化兵棋的认知行为建模方法研究[J]. 系统仿真学报, 2021, 33(9): 2037-2047.
	He Xiaoyuan, Guo Shengming, Wu Lin, et al. Modeling Research of Cognition Behavior for Intelligent Wargaming[J]. Journal of System Simulation, 2021, 33(9): 2037-2047.
26	张驭龙. 面向兵棋推演临机规划任务的知识模型嵌入式强化学习技术[D]. 长沙: 国防科技大学, 2022.
27	刘满, 张宏军, 徐有为, 等. 群队级兵棋实体智能行为决策方法研究[J]. 系统工程与电子技术, 2022, 44(8): 2562-2569.
	Liu Man, Zhang Hongjun, Xu Youwei, et al. Research on Behavior Decision-making of Multi Entities in Group-level Wargame[J]. Systems Engineering and Electronics, 2022, 44(8): 2562-2569.
28	王昶. 战略推演: 获取竞争优势的思维与方法[M]. 北京: 机械工业出版社, 2019.
29	周姚, 夏旻, 莫李龙. 兰德联合一体化应急模型应用及启示[J]. 东南大学学报(哲学社会科学版), 2021, 23(增1): 166-167.
30	李健, 毛翔. 兰德战略评估系统及其影响[J]. 军事运筹与系统工程, 2015, 29(1): 5-12.
31	季明. 美国"翌日"模拟法辅助战略问题决策[J]. 外国军事学术, 2004(9): 34-35.
32	Linick M E, Yurchak J, Spirtas M, et al. Hedgemony: A Game of Strategic Choices[EB/OL]. [2023-02-05]: .
33	司光亚. 战略训练模拟系统原理[M]. 北京: 国防大学出版社, 2011.
34	陈敏, 黄谦, 李坎. 军事战略博弈研讨系统分析与设计[J]. 指挥控制与仿真, 2019, 41(1): 84-89.
	Chen Min, Huang Qian, Li Kan. Analysis and Design of Military Strategy Game Research System[J]. Command Control & Simulation, 2019, 41(1): 84-89.
35	杨镜宇, 唐本富, 吴曦, 等. 面向事件认知的战略博弈系统设计[J]. 军事运筹与系统工程, 2020, 34(3): 59-65.
	Yang Jingyu, Tang Benfu, Wu Xi, et al. Design of Event Cognition Oriented Strategic Game System[J]. Military Operations Research and Systems Engineering, 2020, 34(3): 59-65.
36	吴曦, 孟祥林, 杨镜宇. 下一代战略博弈推演系统研究[J]. 系统仿真学报, 2021, 33(9): 2017-2024.
	Wu Xi, Meng Xianglin, Yang Jingyu. Study on Next-generation Strategic Wargame System[J]. Journal of System Simulation, 2021, 33(9): 2017-2024.
37	赵彬. 基于超对策的军事战略博弈冲突分析[D]. 长沙: 国防科技大学, 2021.
38	于淼, 徐屹泰, 周文, 等. 战略博弈手段结构化表示与手段集构建方法[J]. 国防科技, 2022, 43(5): 57-62.
	Yu Miao, Xu Yitai, Zhou Wen, et al. Structured Representations of Strategic Game Options and Building an Option Set[J]. National Defense Technology, 2022, 43(5): 57-62.
39	李伟, 梁小平. 未战先算, 多算常胜: 战略推演呼唤"智能+"[EB/OL]. (2021-05-18) [2023-07-31]. .
40	徐屹泰, 于淼, 孙晓民, 等. 战略博弈与兵棋推演跨层级联动运行研究[J]. 军事运筹与评估, 2022, 37(2): 73-79.
	Xu Yitai, Yu Miao, Sun Xiaomin, et al. Research on Cross-level Linkage Operation of Strategic Game and Wargaming[J]. Military Operations Research and Assessment, 2022, 37(2): 73-79.
41	Grant T, Kooter B. Comparing OODA and Other Models as Operational View C2 Architecture[C]//10th International Command and Control Research and Technology Symposium the Future of C2. Santa Cruz, CA, USA: [s.n.], 2005: 1-14.
42	李琛, 黄炎焱, 张永亮, 等. Actor-Critic框架下的多智能体决策方法及其在兵棋上的应用[J]. 系统工程与电子技术, 2021, 43(3): 755-762.
	Li Chen, Huang Yanyan, Zhang Yongliang, et al. Multi-agent Decision-making Method Based on Actor-critic Framework and Its Application in Wargame[J]. Systems Engineering and Electronics, 2021, 43(3): 755-762.
43	张振, 黄炎焱, 张永亮, 等. 基于近端策略优化的作战实体博弈对抗算法[J]. 南京理工大学学报, 2021, 45(1): 77-83.
	Zhang Zhen, Huang Yanyan, Zhang Yongliang, et al. Battle Entity Confrontation Algorithm Based on Proximal Policy Optimization[J]. Journal of Nanjing University of Science and Technology, 2021, 45(1): 77-83.
44	Yin Qiyue, Yu Tongtong, Shen Shengqi, et al. Distributed Deep Reinforcement Learning: A Survey and A Multi-player Multi-agent Learning Toolbox[EB/OL]. (2022-12-01) [2023-03-02]. .
45	施伟, 冯旸赫, 程光权, 等. 基于深度强化学习的多机协同空战方法研究[J]. 自动化学报, 2021, 47(7): 1610-1623.
	Shi Wei, Feng Yanghe, Cheng Guangquan, et al. Research on Multi-aircraft Cooperative Air Combat Method Based on Deep Reinforcement Learning[J]. Acta Automatica Sinica, 2021, 47(7): 1610-1623.
46	梁星星, 马扬, 冯旸赫, 等. 基于预测编码的样本自适应行动策略规划[J]. 软件学报, 2022, 33(4): 1477-1500.
	Liang Xingxing, Ma Yang, Feng Yanghe, et al. Sample Adaptive Policy Planning Based on Predictive Coding[J]. Journal of Software, 2022, 33(4): 1477-1500.
47	蒲志强, 易建强, 刘振, 等. 知识和数据协同驱动的群体智能决策方法研究综述[J]. 自动化学报, 2022, 48(3): 627-643.
	Pu Zhiqiang, Yi Jianqiang, Liu Zhen, et al. Knowledge-based and Data-driven Integrating Methodologies for Collective Intelligence Decision Making: A Survey[J]. Acta Automatica Sinica, 2022, 48(3): 627-643.
48	黄凯奇, 兴军亮, 张俊格, 等. 人机对抗智能技术[J]. 中国科学(信息科学), 2020, 50(4): 540-550.
	Huang Kaiqi, Xing Junliang, Zhang Junge, et al. Intelligent Technologies of Human-computer Gaming[J]. Scientia Sinica(Informationis), 2020, 50(4): 540-550.
49	易本胜, 李万顺. 美军战略净评估方法分析[J]. 军事运筹与系统工程, 2012, 26(3): 14-18.
50	易本胜. 净评估: 军事理论生成和转化的有效模式与方法[J]. 军事文摘, 2020(3): 7-11.
51	娄伟. 情景分析方法研究[J]. 未来与发展, 2012, 35(9): 17-26.
	Lou Wei. The Study on Scenario Analysis Method[J]. Future and Development, 2012, 35(9): 17-26.
52	Nguyen M T, Dunn M. Some Methods for Scenario Analysis in Defence Strategic Planning[EB/OL]. [2023-01-10]. .
53	赵晓哲, 郭锐. 军事系统研究的综合集成方法[J]. 系统工程理论与实践, 2004, 24(10): 127-130, 144.
	Zhao Xiaozhe, Guo Rui. Metasynthesis for Research on Military System[J]. Systems Engineering-Theory & Practice, 2004, 24(10): 127-130, 144.
54	王丹力, 郑楠, 刘成林. 综合集成研讨厅体系起源、发展现状与趋势[J]. 自动化学报, 2021, 47(8): 1822-1839.
	Wang Danli, Zheng Nan, Liu Chenglin. Hall for Workshop of Metasynthetic Engineering: The Origin, Development Status and Future[J]. Acta Automatica Sinica, 2021, 47(8): 1822-1839.
55	郑楠, 章颂, 戴汝为. "人-机结合"的综合集成研讨体系[J]. 模式识别与人工智能, 2022, 35(9): 767-773.
	Zheng Nan, Zhang Song, Dai Ruwei. Hall for Workshop of Metasynthetic Engineering Based on Man-machine Integration[J]. Pattern Recognition and Artificial Intelligence, 2022, 35(9): 767-773.
56	徐选华, 尹儇鹏, 钟香玉, 等. 大群体决策理论与方法研究综述: 问题与挑战[J]. 信息与控制, 2021, 50(1): 54-64, 74.
	Xu Xuanhua, Yin Xuanpeng, Zhong Xiangyu, et al. Summary of Research on Theory and Methods in Large-group Decision-making: Problems and Challenges[J]. Information and Control, 2021, 50(1): 54-64, 74.
57	Peterson J C, Bourgin D D, Agrawal M, et al. Using Large-scale Experiments and Machine Learning to Discover Theories of Human Decision-making[J]. Science, 2021, 372(6547): 1209-1214.
58	Schelling T C. The Strategy of Conflict[M]. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1960.
59	Howard N. Paradoxes of Rationality: Theory of Metagames and Political Behavior[M]. Cambridge: MIT Press, 1971.
60	Fraser N M, Hipel K W. Solving Complex Conflicts[J]. IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man and Cybernetics, 1979, 9(12): 805-816.
61	Kilgour D M, Hipel K W, Fang L. The Graph Model for Conflicts With Application to Resource Allocation[J]. IFAC Proceedings Volumes, 1985, 18(14): 265-270.
62	Fang Liping, Hipel K W, Kilgour D M. Interactive Decision Making: The Graph Model for Conflict Resolution[M]. New York: John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 1993.
63	Kilgour D M, Eden C. Handbook of Group Decision and Negotiation[M]. 2nd ed. Cham: Springer International Publishing, 2021.
64	Sage A P. Decision Support Systems Engineering[M]. New York: John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 1991.
65	Zhou Xinyu, Ma Xiaoqi. Progress of Graph Model for Conflict Resolution in Conflict Analysis: A Systematic Review and Bibliometrics Research[J]. Journal of Intelligent & Fuzzy Systems, 2021, 41(6): 5835-5846.
66	Hipel K W, Fang Liping, Kilgour D M. The Graph Model for Conflict Resolution: Reflections on Three Decades of Development[J]. Group Decision and Negotiation, 2020, 29(1): 11-60.
67	Fang Liping, Hipel K W. Looking Back on Decision Making Under Conditions of Conflict[M]//Kilgour D M, Eden C. Handbook of Group Decision and Negotiation. Cham: Springer International Publishing, 2021: 1-21.
68	Hipel K W, Fang Liping. The Graph Model for Conflict Resolution and Decision Support[J]. IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics: Systems, 2021, 51(1): 131-141.
69	Howard N. Confrontation Analysis: How to Win Operations Other Than War[M]. Washington, DC, USA: CCRP Publications, 1999.
70	Bennett P G. Games and Dramas: Rationality and Emotion[J]. Mershon International Studies Review, 1996, 40(S1): 171-175.
71	Bryant J. Conflict Evolution: Tracking the Middle East Conflict With Drama Theory[J]. Group Decision and Negotiation, 2014, 23(6): 1263-1279.
72	Bryant J W. Acting Strategically Using Drama Theory[M]. Boca Raton: CRC Press, 2015.
73	Curry J, Ruggiero D, Sabin P, et al. Modelling the Outcomes of International Crises Using Confrontation Analysis[J]. Simulation & Gaming, 2017, 48(3): 314-328.
74	Curry J, Young M, Perla P P. The Confrontation Analysis Handbook: How to Resolve Confrontations by Eliminating Dilemmas. Innovations in Wargaming[M]. Bristol, UK: History of Wargaming Project, 2017.
75	Smith R, Howard N, Tait A. Commanding Anti-terrorist Coalitions: A Mid-east Illustration[EB/OL]. [2022-10-19]. .
76	Crannell M, Howard N, Norwood G W, et al. A C2 System for 'Winning Hearts and Minds': Tools for Confrontation and Collaboration Analysis[EB/OL]. [2023-01-18]. .
77	Bennett P G. Toward a Theory of Hypergames[J]. Omega, 1977, 5(6): 749-751.
78	Howard N. Soft Game Theory[J]. Information and Decision Technologies, 1990, 16(3): 215-227.
79	Fraser N M, Hipel K W. Conflict Analysis: Models and Resolutions[M]. New York: North-Holland, 1984.
80	Howard N. Drama Theory and Its Relation to Game Theory. Part 1: Dramatic Resolution vs. Rational Solution[J]. Group Decision and Negotiation, 1994, 3(2): 187-206.
81	Howard N. Drama Theory and Its Relation to Game Theory. Part 2: Formal Model of the Resolution Process[J]. Group Decision and Negotiation, 1994, 3(2): 207-235.
82	Zhang Ziqian, Yuan Lei, Li Lihe, et al. Fast Teammate Adaptation in the Presence of Sudden Policy Change[EB/OL]. (2023-05-10) [2023-05-10]. .
83	Yu Chao, Yang Xinyi, Gao Jiaxuan, et al. Asynchronous Multi-agent Reinforcement Learning for Efficient Real-time Multi-robot Cooperative Exploration[EB/OL]. [2023-01-09]. .
84	Zhang Bin, Li Lijuan, Xu Zhiwei, et al. Inducing Stackelberg Equilibrium Through Spatio-temporal Sequential Decision-making in Multi-agent Reinforcement Learning[EB/OL]. [2023-04-20]. .
85	南江霞, 王盼盼, 李登峰. 非合作-合作两型博弈的Shapley值纯策略纳什均衡解求解方法[J]. 中国管理科学, 2021, 29(5): 202-210.
	Jiangxia Nan, Wang Panpan, Li Dengfeng. A Solution Method for Shapley-based Equilibrium Strategies of Biform Games[J]. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2021, 29(5): 202-210.
86	Kovach N S, Gibson A S, Lamont G B. Hypergame Theory: A Model for Conflict, Misperception, and Deception[J]. Game Theory, 2015, 2015: 570639.
87	罗俊仁, 张万鹏, 苏炯铭, 等.多智能体博弈学习研究进展[J/OL]. 系统工程与电子技术. (2022-06-27) [2022-09-22]. .
	Luo Junren, Zhang Wanpeng, Su Jiongming, et al. Research Progress of Multi-agent Game Theoretic Learning[J]. Systems Engineering and Electronics. (2022-06-27) [2022-09-22]. .
88	Wellman M P. Methods for Empirical Game-theoretic Analysis[C]//Proceedings of the 21st National Conference on Artificial Intelligence. Palo Alto, CA, USA: AAAI Press, 2006: 1552-1555.
89	Muller P, Omidshafiei S, Rowland M, et al. A Generalized Training Approach for Multiagent Learning[C]//ICLR 2020 Conference Blind Submission. New York, USA: ICLR, 2020: 1-26.
90	McAleer S, Lanier J B, Wang K A, et al. XDO: A Double Oracle Algorithm for Extensive-form Games[C]//Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems. San Francisco, CA, USA: Curran Associates, Inc., 2021: 23128-23139.
91	Nagy B. Two Gaps That Need to Be Filled in Order to Trust AI in Complex Battle Scenarios[R]. Monterey, CA: Acquisition Research Program, 2022: 87-109.
92	李彭伟, 李亚钊. 面向事件画像的事理图谱构建方法[J]. 指挥信息系统与技术, 2021, 12(5): 54-60, 69.
	Li Pengwei, Li Yazhao. Event Logic Graph Construction Method for Event Profile[J]. Command Information System and Technology, 2021, 12(5): 54-60, 69.
93	王继昌. 俄罗斯在叙利亚军事行动的主要经验[J]. 中国军事科学, 2016(3): 119-126.
	Wang Jichang. Main Experience of Russia's Military Operations in Syria[J]. China Military Science, 2016(3): 119-126.
94	彭勇, 张淼, 许凯, 等. 建模与仿真服务化研究综述[J/OL]. 自动化学报. (2023-03-28) [2023-04-02]. .
	Peng Yong, Zhang Miao, Xu Kai, et al. Overview of Servitization of Modeling and Simulation[J/OL]. Acta Automatica Sinica. (2023-03-28) [2023-04-02]. .
95	吴琳, 胡晓峰, 陶九阳, 等. 面向智能成长的兵棋推演生态系统[J]. 系统仿真学报, 2021, 33(9): 2048-2058.
	Wu Lin, Hu Xiaofeng, Tao Jiuyang, et al. Wargaming Eco-system for Intelligence Growing[J]. Journal of System Simulation, 2021, 33(9): 2048-2058.
96	林旺群, 李妍, 罗海龙, 等. 面向全域联合作战指挥控制系统总体框架设计[J]. 指挥与控制学报, 2022, 8(1): 14-22.
	Lin Wangqun, Li Yan, Luo Hailong, et al. Overall Framework Design of Command and Control System for All-domain Joint Operations[J]. Journal of Command and Control, 2022, 8(1): 14-22.
97	杨贵民, 班晓娟, 唐炜, 等. 面向战略博弈系统的案例库设计与实现[C]//第三十二届中国控制会议论文集. 西安: 中国自动化学会控制理论专业委员会, 中国系统工程学会, 2013: 1984-1989.
	Yang Guimin, Ban Xiaojuan, Tang Wei, et al. The Design and Realization of Case Database Oriented to Gaming System[C]//Proceedings of the 32nd Chinese Control Conference. Xi'an: Control Theory Professional Committee of China Association of Automation, Chinese Society of Systems Engineering, 2013: 1984-1989.
98	Li Zixuan, Jin Xiaolong, Li Wei, et al. Temporal Knowledge Graph Reasoning Based on Evolutional Representation Learning[C]//Proceedings of the 44th International ACM SIGIR Conference on Research and Development in Information Retrieval. New York, NY, USA: Association for Computing Machinery, 2021: 408-417.
99	Turnitsa C, Blais C, Tolk A. Simulation and Wargaming[M]. Hoboken, NJ, USA: John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 2022.
100	王亮, 权磊, 陈泱. SWOT分析法在军事博弈中的应用研究[J]. 舰船电子工程, 2021, 41(3): 5-9.
	Wang Liang, Quan Lei, Chen Yang. Research on the Application of SWOT Method in Military Game[J]. Ship Electronic Engineering, 2021, 41(3): 5-9.
101	Sandole D J D, Byrne S, Sandole-Staroste I, et al. Handbook of Conflict Analysis and Resolution[M]. London: Routledge, 2008.
102	郑少秋, 梁汝鹏, 吴浩, 等. 人机共生作战决策系统:发展愿景与关键技术[J]. 火力与指挥控制, 2022, 47(7): 1-6, 13.
	Zheng Shaoqiu, Liang Rupeng, Wu Hao, et al. Human-machine Symbiosis Combat Decision-making System: Development Vision and Key Technologies[J]. Fire Control & Command Control, 2022, 47(7): 1-6, 13.
103	Johnson B, Miller M S, Green M J M, et al. Game Theory and Prescriptive Analytics for Naval Wargaming Battle Management Aids[R]. Monterey, CA: Naval Postgraduate School, 2022: 1-61.
104	Lee A. An Exploration of Wargame Methodologies: Manual Adjudication, Data Collection and Analysis[R]. Dartmouth, Nova Scotia: Centre for Operationa Research and Anaysis, 2020: 1-13.
105	Xu Haiyan, Hipel K W, Kilgour D M, et al. Conflict Resolution Using the Graph Model: Strategic Interactions in Competition and Cooperation[M]. Cham: Springer International Publishing, 2018.
106	黄美根, 王维平, 王涛, 等. 基于EC2的无人化作战体系云流化指控架构设计方法[J]. 系统工程与电子技术, 2022, 44(11): 3413-3422.
	Huang Meigen, Wang Weiping, Wang Tao, et al. EC2-based Architecture Design Method of Cloud-flow C2 for Unmanned Combat SoS[J]. Systems Engineering and Electronics, 2022, 44(11): 3413-3422.
107	Waytowich N, Barton S L, Lawhern V, et al. Grounding Natural Language Commands to StarCraft II Game States for Narration-guided Reinforcement Learning[C]//Proceedings Volume 11006, Artificial Intelligence and Machine Learning for Multi-Domain Operations Applications. Bellingham, WA, USA: SPIE, 2019: 110060S.
108	Badalyan R S, Graham A D, Nixt M W, et al. Application of An Artificial Intelligence-enabled Real-time Wargaming System for Naval Tactical Operations[EB/OL]. (2022-09-20) [2023-01-21]. .
109	邱志明, 李恒, 周玉芳, 等. 模拟仿真技术及其在训练领域的应用综述[J]. 系统仿真学报, 2023, 35(6): 1131-1143.
	Qiu Zhiming, Li Heng, Zhou Yufang, et al. Summary of Simulation Technology and Its Application in Training Field[J]. Journal of System Simulation, 2023, 35(6): 1131-1143.
110	杨洋, 况琨, 陈政聿, 等. 基于端云协同体系的预训练大模型及其服务化[J]. 人工智能, 2022(6): 103-120.
111	Li Zixuan, Guan Saiping, Jin Xiaolong, et al. Complex Evolutional Pattern Learning for Temporal Knowledge Graph Reasoning[EB/OL]. (2022-03-20) [2023-02-10]. .
112	Ward M D, Beger A, Cutler J, et al. Comparing GDELT and ICEWS Event Data[J]. Analysis, 2013, 21(1): 267-297.
113	Davis P K, Bracken P. Artificial Intelligence for Wargaming and Modeling[J/OL]. The Journal of Defense Modeling and Simulation. (2022-02-08) [2023-01-25]. .
114	Zhao Y, MacKinnon D J. Leverage ai to Learn, Optimize, and Wargame (LAILOW) for Strategic Laydown and Dispersal (SLD) of the Operating Forces of the Us Navy[R]. Monterey, CA: Acquisition Research Program, 2023: 287-295.
115	吉祥, 蒋锴, 成海东. 全域作战指挥信息系统总体架构及核心支柱[J]. 指挥与控制学报, 2023, 9(2): 225-232.
	Ji Xiang, Jiang Kai, Cheng Haidong. Architecture and Core Pillars of All-domain Operation Command Information System[J]. Journal of Command and Control, 2023, 9(2): 225-232.
116	张大永, 杨镜宇, 马骏, 等. 面向兵棋推演复盘分析的机器学习数据集构建[J/OL].系统仿真学报. (2023-02-16) [2023-08-02]. .
	Zhang Dayong, Yang Jingyu, Ma Jun, et al. Construction of Machine Learning Data Set for the Analysis of the Replay of the Wargaming[J]. Journal of System Simulation. (2023-02-16) [2023-08-02]. .
117	罗俊仁, 张万鹏, 苏炯铭, 等. 面向智能博弈的决策Transformer方法综述[J]. 指挥与控制学报, 2023, 9(1): 9-22.
	Luo Junren, Zhang Wanpeng, Su Jiongming, et al. On Decision-making Transformer Methods for Intelligent Gaming[J]. Journal of Command and Control, 2023, 9(1): 9-22.

博弈模型	行为主体	角色	典型模型	典型应用场景	可扩展性
图博弈	决策者(Decision-Maker)	指挥员	冲突分析与消解	大群体决策	群组(Group)
序贯博弈	参与方(Player)	参谋	不完美信息博弈	序贯决策	种群(Population)
马尔可夫博弈	行为实体(Entity)	战斗员	部分可观马尔可夫博弈	异构实体协同决策	集群(Swarm)

[1]	Yin Laixiang, Li Zhiqiang, Fu Qiongying. Research on Intelligent Statistical Analysis of Wargaming Data Based on NL2SQL [J]. Journal of System Simulation, 2023, 35(9): 2000-2010.
[2]	Dayong Zhang, Jingyu Yang, Xi Wu. Research on Intelligent Prediction Method of Wargaming Air Mission [J]. Journal of System Simulation, 2023, 35(1): 212-220.
[3]	Junren Luo, Wanpeng Zhang, Weilin Yuan, Zhenzhen Hu, Shaofei Chen, Jing Chen. Research on Opponent Modeling Framework for Multi-agent Game Confrontation [J]. Journal of System Simulation, 2022, 34(9): 1941-1955.
[4]	Huimin Chai, Yong Zhang, Xinyue Li, Yanan Song. Aerial Target Threat Assessment Method based on Deep Learning [J]. Journal of System Simulation, 2022, 34(7): 1459-1467.
[5]	Hu Xiaofeng, Qi Dawei. Intelligent Wargaming System: Change Needed by Next Generation Need to be Changed [J]. Journal of System Simulation, 2021, 33(9): 1997-2009.
[6]	He Xiaoyuan, Guo Shengming, Wu Lin, Li Dong, Xu Xiao, Li Li. Modeling Research of Cognition Behavior for Intelligent Wargaming [J]. Journal of System Simulation, 2021, 33(9): 2037-2047.
[7]	Wu Lin, Hu Xiaofeng, Tao Jiuyang, He Xiaoyuan. Wargaming Eco-system for Intelligence Growing [J]. Journal of System Simulation, 2021, 33(9): 2048-2058.
[8]	Zhang Jiajun, Qian Xiaochao, Zhou Jinpeng, Wang Xuanling, Lu Zhifeng. Simulation-based An Exploratory Analysis of Drone Air strike on Saudi oilfields [J]. Journal of System Simulation, 2020, 32(6): 1195-1200.
[9]	Wang Bao, Gao Linjie, Juan Zhicai. Analysis of Lane Changing Conflict Based on TTA in Expressway Weaving Area [J]. Journal of System Simulation, 2018, 30(9): 3306-3311.
[10]	Liu Haiyang, Tang Yubo, Hu Xiaofeng, Qiao Guangpeng. Research on Evaluation Framework of COA Based on Wargaming [J]. Journal of System Simulation, 2018, 30(11): 4115-4123.
[11]	Sun Zejian, Si Guangya, Liu Yang. Research and Implementation of Question Answering System Oriented Wargaming Based on AIML [J]. Journal of System Simulation, 2017, 29(10): 2489-2496.