系统仿真学报 ›› 2020, Vol. 32 ›› Issue (8): 1413-1424.doi: 10.16182/j.issn1004731x.joss.20-0442
• 专栏:仿真可信度评估 • 下一篇
周玉臣, 林圣琳, 马萍, 李伟, 杨明
收稿日期:
2020-07-03
修回日期:
2020-07-26
出版日期:
2020-08-18
发布日期:
2020-08-13
作者简介:
周玉臣(1991-),男,山东济南,博士,研究方向为复杂系统评估、实验设计等;马萍(1970-),女,辽宁鞍山,教授,博士,研究方向为复杂系统仿真与评估等。
基金资助:
Zhou Yuchen, Lin Shengling, Ma Ping, Li Wei, Yang Ming
Received:
2020-07-03
Revised:
2020-07-26
Online:
2020-08-18
Published:
2020-08-13
摘要: 效能是评估武器装备的重要指标,武器装备效能评估可以为武器装备规划论证、设计研制、作战运用等提供决策支持。随着数字线程、数字孪生在武器装备全寿命周期的应用,效能评估面临复杂作战场景评估、多源异构数据评估、昂贵仿真的评估优化、泛在评估、敏捷评估等一系列挑战。综述了效能评估相关概念、发展历程,分析了武器装备效能评估面临的问题;进而给出了武器装备效能评估解决方案,总结了数字时代武器装备效能评估研究方向。
中图分类号:
周玉臣, 林圣琳, 马萍, 李伟, 杨明. 武器装备效能评估研究进展[J]. 系统仿真学报, 2020, 32(8): 1413-1424.
Zhou Yuchen, Lin Shengling, Ma Ping, Li Wei, Yang Ming. Research Progress on Weapon and Equipment Effectiveness Evaluation[J]. Journal of System Simulation, 2020, 32(8): 1413-1424.
[1] | Hootman J C, Whitcomb C.A military effectiveness analysis and decision making framework for naval ship design and acquisition[J]. Naval Engineers Journal (S0028-1425), 2005, 117(3): 43-61. |
[2] | 焦松. 武器装备效能仿真评估关键问题研究[D]. 哈尔滨: 哈尔滨工业大学, 2014.Jiao Song.Research on key problems of the simulation evaluation for weapon effectiveness[D]. Harbin: Harbin Institute of Technology, 2014. |
[3] | WSEIAC. Final report of task group I: Requirement methodology[R]. 1965. |
[4] | Dordick H S.An introduction to system effectiveness [R]. Rand. 1965. |
[5] | Hayward P.The measurement of combat effectiveness[J]. Operations Research (S0030-364X), 1968, 16(2): 314-323. |
[6] | Tillman F A, Lie C H, Hwang C L.Simulation model for mission effectiveness for military systems[J]. IEEE Transactions on Reliability (S0018-9529), 1978, 27(3): 191-194. |
[7] | Rau J G.Measures of effectiveness handbook[R]. 1974. |
[8] | Bouthonnier V, Levis A H.System effectiveness analysis of C3 systems[J]. IEEE Transactions on System, Man, and Cybernetics (S2168-2232), 1984, 14(1): 48-54. |
[9] | Cpthier P H, Levis A H.Timeliness and measures of in command and control[J]. IEEE Transactions on System, Man, and Cybernetics (S2168-2232), 1986, 16(6): 844-853. |
[10] | Sivazlian B D.Aircraft sortie effectiveness model[J]. Naval Research Logistics (S0894-069X), 1989, 36(2): 127-137. |
[11] | Jung H D.Computer study of air defense gun effectiveness[D]. Monterey: Naval Postgraduate School. 1987. |
[12] | Gallagher M A, Kelly E J.New methodology for military force structure analysis[J]. Operations Research (S0030-364X), 1991, 39(6): 877-885. |
[13] | Gluckman A G, Celmins A.Cost effectiveness analysis using fuzzy set theory[R]. U.S. Army Research Laboratory. 1993. |
[14] | Kohlberg I, Greer W.Weapons systems effectiveness and minimum cost for ballistic missile defense alternatives[C]. AIAA missile system conference. Reston: AIAA, 1996. |
[15] | Bowden F, Gabrisch C, Davies M.C3I systems analysis using the distributed interactive C3I effectiveness (DICE) simulation[C]. IEEE International Conference on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics. Los Alamitos: IEEE, 1997: 4326-4331. |
[16] | Pawlowski T J.Command, control, communications, intelligence, electronic warfare measures of effectiveness (C3IEW MOE) [R]. Military Operations Research Society. 1992. |
[17] | Horn D, Colvert P, Scrip C.THAAD integrated system effectiveness simulation (TISES) theater high altitude area defense[C]. AIAA Modeling and Simulation Technologies Conference. Reston: AIAA, 1997. |
[18] | Davis P K.Exploratory analysis enabled by multiresolultion multiperspective modeling[C]. Winter Simulation Conference. Los Alamitos: IEEE, 2000: 293-301. |
[19] | Pinder J D.Evaluating future force options for the U.S. army[D]. Santa Monica: RAND Graduate School, 2000. |
[20] | Hwang J S.Analysis of effectiveness of CEC (cooperative engagement capability) using Schutzer’s C2 theory[D]. Monterey: Naval Postgraduate School, 2003. |
[21] | Lund F.Historic weapon system cost effectiveness comparison[C]. AIAA Aerospace Sciences Meeting Including the New Horizons Forum and Aerospace Exposition. Reston: AIAA, 2009. |
[22] | Poropudas J, Virtanen K.Analyzing air combat simulation results with dynamic Bayesian networks[C]. Winter Simulation Conference. Los Alamitos: IEEE, 2007: 1370-1377. |
[23] | Gipson I G.Effectiveness of the U.S. missile defense capabilities as a deterrent to the North Korean missile[D]. Monterey: Naval Postgraduate School, 2007. |
[24] | Davis P K, Shaver R D, Beck J.Portfolio-analysis methods for assessing capability options[R]. RAND. 2008. |
[25] | Perry W, Button R W, Braken J, et al.Measures of effectiveness for the information-age navy: the effects of network-centric operations on combat outcomes[R]. Rand. 2002. |
[26] | Darilek R, Perry W, Bracken J, et al.Measures of effectiveness for the information-age army[R]. Rand. 2001. |
[27] | Combs R.Assessing strategic effectiveness in the war on terrorism[R]. U.S. Army War College. 2006. |
[28] | Sutherland S P.Measuring effectiveness in conflict environments[D]. Monterey: Naval postgraduate school. 2009. |
[29] | Stumborg M F.The impact of gun dimensions on the operational effectiveness of a naval surface fleet equipped with long range electromagnetic guns[J]. IEEE Transactions on Magnetics (S0018-9464), 2001, 37(1): 498-501. |
[30] | Post J, Bennett M, Hall R.The cost and effectiveness of alternative space radar constellations[C]. Space. Reston: AIAA, 2006. |
[31] | Fager C F.Weaponeering the future direct energy weapons effectiveness now and tomorrow[R]. Air University. 2007. |
[32] | Ender T, Leurck R F, Weaver B, et al.Systems-of-systems analysis of ballistic missile defense architecture effectiveness through surrogate modeling and simulation[J]. IEEE Systems Journal (S2222-6362), 2010, 4(2): 156-166. |
[33] | Mezzacappa E.Effectiveness testing of non-lethal weapons[J]. Journal of Defense Modeling and Simulation: Applications, Methodology, Technology (S1937-9234), 2014, 11(2): 91-101. |
[34] | Au T A, Hoek P J, Lo S.Combat analysis of joint force options using agent-based simulation[C]. 2018 Military Communications and Information Systems Conference. Los Alamitos: IEEE, 2018. |
[35] | Connors C D, Miller J O, Lunday B J.Using agent-based modeling and a designed experiment to simulate and analyze a new air-to-air missile[J]. Journal of Defense Modeling and Simulation: Applications, Methodology, Technology (S1548-5129), 2016, 13(3): 321-330. |
[36] | Hendrickson P, Sarkani S, Mazzuchi T A.Benchmark requirement decision making tool to optimize effectiveness of weapon system modifications[J]. International Journal of Defense Acquisition Management (S1940-3445), 2013, 5(1): 1-19. |
[37] | Grzesik N.Fuzzy sets in aircraft system efficiency evaluation[J]. Aircraft Engineering and Aerospace Technology (S1748-8842), 2016, 88(6): 707-716. |
[38] | Jung W I, Lowe L, Rabelo L, et al.A methodology on guiding effectiveness-focused training of the weapon operator using big data and VC simulations[J]. SAE International Journal of Aerospace (S1687-5966), 2017, 10(2): 57-64. |
[39] | Dillenburger S P, Jordan J D, Cochran J K.Pareto-optimality for lethality and collateral risk in the airstrike multiobjective problem[J]. Journal of the Operational Research Society (S0160-5682), 2019, 70(7): 1051-1064. |
[40] | Hocaoğlu M F.Weapon target assignment optimization for land based multi-air defense systems: A goal programming approach[J]. Computers & Industrial Engineering (S0360-8352), 2019, 128: 681-689. |
[41] | Mroczek A J.Determining the cost-effectiveness of nano satellites[D]. Monterey: Naval Postgraduate School, 2014. |
[42] | Sabatini R.Innovative flight test instrumentation and techniques for airborne laser systems performance analysis and mission effectiveness evaluation[C]. IEEE international workshop on metrology for aerospace. Los Alamitos: IEEE, 2014. |
[43] | Lee S D.Routing UAVS to Co-optimize mission effectiveness and network performance with dynamic programming[D]. Wright-Patterson AFB: Airforce Institute of Technology, 2011. |
[44] | Menthe L, Hura M, Rhodes C.The effectiveness of remotely piloted aircraft in a permissive hunter-killer scenario[R]. Rand. 2014. |
[45] | Kaymal T.Unmanned aircraft systems for maritime operations[C]. International Conference on Unmanned Aircraft Systems(ICUAS). Los Alamitos: IEEE, 2016: 763-768. |
[46] | Ozcan B Y.Effectiveness of unmanned aerial vehicles in helping secure a border characterized by rough terrain and active terrorists[D]. Monterey: Naval Postgraduate School, 2013. |
[47] | Domerçant J C, Mavris D.Understanding and evaluating command & control effectiveness by measuring battlespace awareness[C]. The 18th International Command & Control Research & Technology Symposium (ICCRTS). Alexandria: International C2 Institute, 2014. |
[48] | Czarnecki J E.C2 effectiveness and operational success an exploration[C]. The 16th International Command and Control Research and Technology Symposium. Quebec: International C2 Institute, 2012. |
[49] | Soh S S.Determining intelligence, surveillance and reconnaissance (ISR) system effectiveness, and integration as part of force protection and system survivability[D]. Monterey: Naval Postgraduate School, 2013. |
[50] | Romich A, Lan G H, Smith J C.A robust sensor covering and communication problem[J]. Naval Research Logistics (S0894-069X), 2015, 62(7): 583-594. |
[51] | Maybury M T.Global Horizons Final Report-United States Air force Global Science and Technology Vision[R]. U.S. Air Force. 2013. |
[52] | 张冰, 李欣, 万欣欣. 从数字孪生到数字工程建模仿真迈入新时代[J]. 系统仿真学报, 2019, 31(3): 369-376.Zhang Bing, Li Xin, Wan Xinxin.From digital twin to digital engineering modeling and simulation entering a new era. journal of system simulation[J]. Journal of System Simulation, 2019, 31(3): 369-376. |
[53] | Watson M D, Kelley G W.Application of system operational effectiveness methodology to space launch vehicle development and operations[C]. Reston: AIAA, 2012. |
[54] | 裴云. 中程空地导弹武器系统作战效能评估[J]. 系统工程与电子技术, 2004, 26(10): 1435-1438.Pei Yun.Assessments of the middle-distance air-to-surface missile weapon systems’ combat efficiency[J]. Systems Engineering and Electronics, 2004, 26(10): 1435-1438. |
[55] | 孙海虹, 张平定. 预警机作战效能评估分析[J]. 弹箭与制导学报, 2004, 24(3): 399-401.Sun Haihong, Zhang Pingding.Analysis on the operational effective evaluation of early warning aircraft system[J]. Journal of Projectiles, Rockets, Missiles and Guidance, 2004, 24(3): 399-401. |
[56] | 黄俊, 武哲. 作战飞机的空-地攻击效能评估[J]. 航空学报, 1999, 20(1): 69-71.Huang Jun, Wu Zhe.Assessments of air-to-surface target attacking effectiveness for a combat aircraft[J]. Acta Aeronautica Et Astronautica Sinica, 1999, 20(1): 69-71. |
[57] | 关成启, 杨涤, 关世义. 导弹武器系统效能评估方法研究[J]. 系统工程与电子技术, 2000, 22(7): 32-36.Guan Chengqi, Yang Di, Guan Shiyi.Study of effectiveness evaluation method for guided weapon systems[J]. Systems Engineering and Electronics, 2000, 22(7): 32-36. |
[58] | 杨峰, 张学斌, 王维平, 等. 导弹作战效能仿真评估系统体系结构[J]. 国防科技大学学报, 1999, 21(1): 17-20.Yang Feng, Zhang Xuebin, Wang Weiping, et al.The architecture of the simulation-based evaluation system for missile effectiveness[J]. Journal of National University of Defense Technology, 1999, 21(1): 17-20. |
[59] | 许相莉, 胡晓峰. 一种基于复杂网络理论的网络空间作战效能评估指标体系框架[J]. 军事运筹与系统工程, 2014, 28(1): 33-41. |
[60] | 杨明, 焦松, 李伟. 武器作战效能参数化仿真评估技术研究[J]. 北京理工大学学报, 2013, 33(12): 1269-1273.Yang Ming, Jiao Shuang, Li Wei.Parameterized simulation evaluation technology for operational effectiveness of weapon[J]. Transactions of Beijing Institute of Technology, 2013, 33(12): 1269-1273. |
[61] | 周健, 龚春林, 粟华, 等. 飞行器体系优化设计问题[J]. 航空学报, 2018, 39(11): 102-114.Zhou Jian, Gong Chunlin, Su Hua, et al.Optimal design problem of system of systems of flight vehicle[J]. Acta Aeronautica Et Astronautica Sinica, 2018, 39(11): 102-114. |
[62] | 王庆龙, 王智学, 何红悦, 等. 基于模糊-云模型的C4ISR系统效能需求建模与分析方法[J]. 系统工程与电子技术, 2016, 38(9): 2065-2071.Wang Qinglong, Wang Zhixue, He Hongyue, et al.Modeling and analysis method to C4ISR system for efficiency requirements based on fuzzy cloud model[J]. Systems Engineering and Electronics, 2016, 38(9): 2065-2071. |
[63] | Zhao D L, Dou Y J, Zhao Q S, et al.The method to evaluate the command and control effectiveness of operational system under uncertain threat situation[C]. Chinese Control and Decision Conference. Los Alamitos: IEEE, 2016: 5701-5706. |
[64] | Zhang R W, Song B F, Pei Y, et al.Agent-based analysis of multi-uav area monitoring mission effectiveness[C]. AIAA AVIATION Forum-AIAA Modeling and Simulation Technologies Conference. Reston: AIAA, 2017. |
[65] | Dong Z N, Zhang M Y, Liu Y M.Control Method of Manned/Unmanned Aerial Vehicle Cooperative Formation Based on Mission Effectiveness[C]. Chinese Guidance, Navigation and Control Conference. Los Alamitos: IEEE, 2016: 881-888. |
[66] | 钱晓超, 唐伟, 陈伟, 等. 面向关键能力的陆军全域作战体系贡献率评估[J]. 系统仿真学报, 2018, 30(12): 4786-4793.Qian Xiaochao, Tang Wei, Chen Wei, et al.Evaluation of contribution of army combined arms in all-domains weapon system-of-systems based on critical capability[J]. Journal of System Simulation, 2018, 30(12): 4786-4793. |
[67] | 杨克巍, 杨志伟, 谭跃进, 等. 面向体系贡献率的装备体系评估方法研究综述[J]. 系统工程与电子技术, 2019, 41(2): 311-321.Yang Kewei, Yang Zhiwei, Tan Yuejin, et al.Review of the evaluation methods of equipment system of systems facing the contribution rate[J]. Systems Engineering and Electronics, 2019, 41(2): 311-321. |
[68] | 罗承昆, 陈云翔, 王莉莉, 等. 基于作战环和改进信息熵的体系效能评估方法[J]. 系统工程与电子技术, 2019, 41(1): 73-80.Luo Chengkun, Chen Yunxiang, Wang Lili, et al.Effectiveness evaluation method of system-of-systems based on operation loop and improved information entropy[J]. Systems Engineering and Electronics, 2019, 41(1): 73-80. |
[69] | 林圣琳. 面向复杂仿真的评估与优化方法研究[D]. 哈尔滨: 哈尔滨工业大学, 2020.Lin Shenglin.Complex simulation-oriented assessment and optimization methods[D]. Harbin: Harbin Institute of Technology, 2020. |
[70] | 钱晓超. 考虑不确定性影响的仿真模型验证及校准方法研究[D]. 哈尔滨: 哈尔滨工业大学, 2016.Qian Xiaochao.Research on simulation model validation and calibration methods under uncertainty[D]. Harbin: Harbin Institute of Technology, 2016. |
[71] | 林圣琳, 李伟, 钱晓超, 等.基于复杂昂贵仿真的体系效能多目标优化[J/OL]. 控制与决策, 2019. 10.13195/j.kzyjc.2019.0844.Lin Shenglin, Li Wei, Qian Xiaochao, et al.Complex and expensive simulation based multi-objective optimization to system-of-system effectiveness[J/OL]. Control and Decision, 2019. 10.13195/j.kzyjc.2019.0844. |
[72] | 刘志钊. 武器装备效能仿真评估与优化方法研究[D]. 哈尔滨: 哈尔滨工业大学, 2016.Liu Zhizhao.Research on the simulation evaluation and optimization methods of weapon effectiveness[D] Harbin: Harbin Institute of Technology, 2016. |
[73] | 周玉臣. 复杂仿真模型验证方法研究[D]. 哈尔滨: 哈尔滨工业大学, 2019.Zhou Yuchen.Research on validation method for complex simulation model[D]. Harbin: Harbin Institute of Technology, 2019. |
[74] | Fang K, Zhou Y C, Ma P.An adaptive sequential experiment design method for model validation[J]. Chinese Journal of Aeronautics (S1000-9361), 2020, 33(6): 1661-1672. |
[75] | Ma P, Zhou Y C, Shang X B, et al.Firing accuracy evaluation of electromagnetic railgun based on multicriteria optimal Latin hypercube design[J]. IEEE Transactions on Plasma Science (S0093-3813), 2017, 45(7): 1503-1511. |
[1] | 张高峰, 吴亮. 复杂电磁环境下水面舰艇防空反导作战效能评估[J]. 系统仿真学报, 2022, 34(3): 640-650. |
[2] | 李锋, 魏莹. 社会学习和参照点效应对企业产品决策的影响[J]. 系统仿真学报, 2022, 34(2): 234-246. |
[3] | 张子伟, 郭齐胜, 董志明, 高昂, 王艺霏. 体系作战效能评估与优化方法综述[J]. 系统仿真学报, 2022, 34(2): 303-313. |
[4] | 樊长佳, 杜炎秋, 梁笛, 胡凯, 黄葭燕. COVID-19期间上海市应急医疗资源配置建模与仿真[J]. 系统仿真学报, 2022, 34(1): 93-103. |
[5] | 司光亚, 王艳正. 新一代大型计算机兵棋系统面临的挑战与思考[J]. 系统仿真学报, 2021, 33(9): 2010-2016. |
[6] | 李文翔, 李晔, 董洁霜, 李一鸣. 引入碳交易机制的新能源汽车发展路径研究[J]. 系统仿真学报, 2021, 33(6): 1451-1465. |
[7] | 王凌, 吴楚格, 范文慧. 边缘计算资源分配与任务调度优化综述[J]. 系统仿真学报, 2021, 33(3): 509-520. |
[8] | 李锋, 魏莹. 复杂网络对羊群效应现象影响的仿真研究[J]. 系统仿真学报, 2021, 33(3): 539-553. |
[9] | 张琪, 曾俊杰, 许凯, 秦龙, 尹全军. 基于机器学习的计算机生成兵力行为建模研究综述[J]. 系统仿真学报, 2021, 33(2): 280-287. |
[10] | 雷永林, 朱智, 甘斌, 雷森, 陈永. 基于仿真的复杂武器系统作战效能评估框架研究[J]. 系统仿真学报, 2020, 32(9): 1654-1663. |
[11] | 李妮, 李玉红, 龚光红, 黄晓冬. 基于深度学习的体系作战效能智能评估及优化[J]. 系统仿真学报, 2020, 32(8): 1425-1435. |
[12] | 于道林, 朱文海, 庆骁, 施国强. 军工制造业数字化转型的系统方法论[J]. 系统仿真学报, 2020, 32(3): 347-352. |
[13] | 王剑, 司徒陈麒, 袁胜强. 基于多主体和前景理论的应急风险决策仿真研究[J]. 系统仿真学报, 2020, 32(3): 353-361. |
[14] | 李锋, 魏莹. 时序网络视角下网络舆情的演化模型研究[J]. 系统仿真学报, 2020, 32(3): 394-403. |
[15] | 邵松世, 阮旻智, 张志华. 基于库存状态的备件初始配置及采购优化模型[J]. 系统仿真学报, 2020, 32(3): 509-517. |
阅读次数 | ||||||
全文 |
|
|||||
摘要 |
|
|||||