Journal of System Simulation ›› 2026, Vol. 38 ›› Issue (4): 974-987.doi: 10.16182/j.issn1004731x.joss.25-0216
• Papers • Previous Articles Next Articles
Liang Binhao, Wei Jingxuan, Liang Fengqin
Received:2025-03-21
Revised:2025-05-16
Online:2026-04-20
Published:2026-04-22
Contact:
Wei Jingxuan
CLC Number:
Liang Binhao, Wei Jingxuan, Liang Fengqin. Large-scale Multi-objective Evolutionary Algorithm Based on Multi-region Dynamic Grouping[J]. Journal of System Simulation, 2026, 38(4): 974-987.
Table 1
Statistical results of IGD values obtained by comparison algorithms and MRADG on bi-objective LSMOP1–LSMOP9 test problems
| 测试问题 | 目标维度 | CCGDE3 | MOEA/DVA | LCSA | LSMOF | FLEA | LERD | MRADG |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| LSMOP1 | 100 | 2.577 8e+0(5.40e-1)- | 4.390 6e-2(2.36e-3)- | 3.362 3e-1(3.09e-2)- | 2.075 1e-2(9.50e-3)- | 4.877 9e-1(1.27e-1)- | 6.168 8e-3(4.74e-4)+ | 1.636 9e-2(7.41e-3) |
| 500 | 4.445 6e+0(3.46e-1)- | 4.825 0e+0(2.10e-1)- | 5.719 1e-1(9.33e-2)- | 2.832 8e-1(3.25e-2)- | 5.846 0e-1(1.11e-1)- | 5.724 4e-1(1.28e-1)- | 1.900 8e-1(9.19e-3) | |
| 1 000 | 5.352 1e+0(3.13e-1)- | 7.644 6e+0(2.22e-1)- | 5.090 5e-1(1.33e-1)- | 3.962 6e-1(4.28e-2)- | 6.145 7e-1(8.69e-2)- | 1.211 8e+0(1.23e-1)- | 2.366 8e-1(2.20e-2) | |
| 1 500 | 5.538 7e+0(2.67e-1)- | 8.898 0e+0(1.82e-1)- | 5.778 0e-1(1.15e-1)- | 4.471 4e-1(6.58e-2)- | 6.201 7e-1(8.34e-2)- | 1.384 3e+0(1.66e-1)- | 2.745 5e-1(2.61e-2) | |
| 2 000 | 5.743 8e+0(2.43e-1)- | 9.637 0e+0(1.26e-1)- | 4.729 3e-1(1.26e-1)- | 4.518 9e-1(4.01e-2)- | 5.916 2e-1(9.14e-2)- | 1.490 0e+0(2.05e-1)- | 3.173 0e-1(3.58e-2) | |
| LSMOP2 | 100 | 2.136 8e-1(8.53e-3)- | 2.009 1e-1(2.00e-3)- | 8.301 0e-2(4.06e-3)- | 2.913 4e-2(2.72e-3)- | 7.625 1e-2(9.54e-3)- | 3.438 9e-2(1.00e-2)- | 2.195 4e-2(5.02e-3) |
| 500 | 7.193 7e-2(8.04e-4)- | 7.214 0e-2(3.42e-4)- | 3.325 5e-2(2.34e-4)- | 1.676 8e-2(7.15e-4)- | 1.986 2e-2(5.94e-4)- | 3.453 9e-2(5.95e-3)- | 1.572 5e-2(1.88e-3) | |
| 1 000 | 3.990 1e-2(4.95e-4)- | 4.032 0e-2(4.09e-4)- | 1.915 7e-2(3.44e-4)- | 1.161 2e-2(2.99e-4)- | 1.123 6e-2(4.42e-4)- | 2.159 4e-2(1.43e-3)- | 1.052 4e-2(1.09e-3) | |
| 1 500 | 2.802 0e-2(3.98e-4)- | 2.852 9e-2(3.17e-4)- | 1.455 0e-2(2.72e-4)- | 9.837 7e-3(3.92e-4)- | 8.967 7e-3(9.26e-4)- | 1.621 9e-2(7.95e-4)- | 8.299 2e-3(4.73e-4) | |
| 2 000 | 2.170 1e-2(3.49e-4)- | 2.302 7e-2(5.93e-4)- | 1.273 4e-2(2.23e-4)- | 8.727 4e-3(4.06e-4)- | 8.542 2e-3(1.71e-3)- | 1.286 2e-2(3.73e-4)- | 7.196 5e-3(5.05e-4) | |
| LSMOP3 | 100 | 1.272 4e+1(3.08e+0)- | 3.653 2e+0(1.81e+0)- | 6.488 3e-1(1.20e-3)+ | 1.425 8e+0(3.51e-2)- | 1.511 4e+0(2.57e-3)- | 6.708 6e-1(3.48e-2)+ | 1.101 4e+0(1.29e-1) |
| 500 | 2.357 2e+1(2.01e+0)- | 7.491 6e+2(6.22e+2)- | 1.028 5e+0(3.96e-2)+ | 1.559 4e+0(2.42e-3)+ | 1.565 7e+0(1.71e-3)+ | 4.905 9e+0(5.29e+0)- | 1.571 2e+0(2.26e-3) | |
| 1 000 | 2.814 3e+1(1.07e+0)- | 9.563 3e+2(8.64e+2)- | 1.483 9e+0(1.61e-2)+ | 1.569 5e+0(1.52e-3)+ | 1.573 5e+0(1.08e-3)+ | 1.161 4e+1(5.77e+0)- | 1.580 0e+0(2.31e-3) | |
| 1 500 | 3.001 3e+1(9.72e-1)- | 1.115 4e+3(1.13e+3)- | 1.586 0e+0(2.19e-4)- | 1.573 6e+0(7.69e-4)+ | 1.576 1e+0(9.62e-5)+ | 1.342 5e+1(2.51e+0)- | 1.582 0e+0(2.81e-3) | |
| 2 000 | 3.140 3e+1(1.03e+0)- | 8.853 9e+2(9.04e+2)- | 1.587 8e+0(1.73e-4)- | 1.575 0e+0(9.45e-4)+ | 1.577 0e+0(7.79e-4)+ | 1.372 2e+1(2.58e+0)- | 1.584 6e+0(1.68e-3) | |
| LSMOP4 | 100 | 3.075 3e-1(2.37e-2)- | 1.053 8e-1(1.79e-2)- | 1.617 6e-1(9.49e-3)- | 2.109 5e-2(1.08e-3)≈ | 1.737 9e-1(1.66e-2)- | 2.837 6e-2(1.93e-3)- | 2.258 9e-2(2.89e-3) |
| 500 | 1.138 9e-1(2.08e-3)- | 1.053 2e-1(7.37e-4)- | 8.792 4e-2(1.94e-3)- | 4.000 4e-2(1.55e-3)- | 5.398 4e-2(2.57e-3)- | 5.184 6e-2(5.26e-3)- | 2.902 2e-2(2.06e-3) | |
| 1 000 | 6.937 4e-2(1.05e-3)- | 6.944 1e-2(4.11e-4)- | 5.776 3e-2(9.57e-4)- | 2.623 2e-2(7.97e-4)- | 3.018 2e-2(1.51e-3)- | 3.464 6e-2(3.65e-3)- | 2.201 6e-2(3.35e-4) | |
| 1 500 | 5.128 3e-2(1.12e-3)- | 5.238 9e-2(2.40e-4)- | 5.002 9e-2(2.44e-4)- | 1.993 3e-2(7.25e-4)- | 2.174 1e-2(1.05e-3)- | 2.513 0e-2(1.97e-3)- | 1.661 1e-2(2.98e-4) | |
| 2 000 | 4.061 5e-2(7.30e-4)- | 4.224 8e-2(2.81e-4)- | 3.905 0e-2(2.78e-4)- | 1.613 1e-2(5.57e-4)- | 1.799 8e-2(9.52e-4)- | 2.101 9e-2(1.48e-3)- | 1.370 7e-2(2.80e-4) | |
| LSMOP5 | 100 | 5.597 1e+0(8.04e-1)- | 1.032 5e-1(6.73e-3)- | 1.925 4e-1(6.03e-2)- | 3.642 1e-1(1.71e-1)- | 7.420 9e-1(1.11e-16)- | 1.117 6e-1(1.33e-1)- | 1.017 4e-2(1.01e-3) |
| 500 | 1.053 2e+1(6.84e-1)- | 1.134 3e+1(5.43e-1)- | 7.420 9e-1(1.11e-16)- | 7.420 9e-1(1.11e-16)- | 7.420 9e-1(1.11e-16)- | 6.650 8e-1(2.50e-1)≈ | 7.420 2e-1(2.92e-4) | |
| 1 000 | 1.229 8e+1(8.08e-1)- | 1.680 4e+1(4.89e-1)- | 7.420 9e-1(1.11e-16)- | 7.420 9e-1(1.11e-16)- | 7.420 9e-1(1.11e-16)- | 3.380 3e+0(1.05e+0)- | 7.420 9e-1(1.11e-16) | |
| 1 500 | 1.320 4e+1(9.28e-1)- | 1.907 3e+1(3.99e-1)- | 7.420 9e-1(1.11e-16)- | 7.420 9e-1(1.11e-16)- | 7.420 9e-1(1.11e-16)- | 4.492 0e+0(6.37e-1)- | 7.420 9e-1(1.11e-16) | |
| 2 000 | 1.324 4e+1(6.85e-1)- | 2.057 9e+1(3.12e-1)- | 7.420 9e-1(1.11e-16)--- | 7.420 9e-1(1.11e-16)- | 7.420 9e-1(1.11e-16)- | 5.024 3e+0(7.11e-1)- | 7.420 9e-1(1.11e-16) | |
| LSMOP6 | 100 | 1.093 6e+0(2.70e-2)- | 1.039 5e+0(4.97e-2)- | 5.894 2e-1(3.83e-3)- | 4.364 9e-1(1.04e-2)≈ | 4.045 0e-1(2.08e-1)≈ | 5.393 1e-1(8.20e-2)- | 4.119 8e-1(9.58e-2) |
| 500 | 8.132 2e-1(2.45e-3)- | 1.124 6e+3(8.92e+2)- | 6.792 2e-1(7.20e-4)- | 3.344 5e-1(1.25e-2)+ | 2.473 8e-1(1.18e-1)+ | 7.301 2e-1(6.42e-2)- | 6.763 9e-1(4.25e-3) | |
| 1 000 | 7.752 8e-1(4.21e-4)- | 1.540 0e+3(1.11e+3)- | 6.764 7e-1(2.41e-4)≈ | 3.234 5e-1(1.33e-2)+ | 3.005 5e-1(1.19e-1)+ | 7.083 1e-1(7.23e-2)- | 6.747 4e-1(4.97e-3) | |
| 1 500 | 7.630 6e-1(1.23e-4)- | 2.056 4e+3(1.74e+3)- | 6.752 0e-1(1.71e-4)- | 3.162 0e-1(6.78e-3)+ | 3.257 1e-1(9.76e-2)+ | 7.200 4e-1(4.50e-2)- | 6.745 3e-1(2.40e-3) | |
| 2 000 | 7.573 3e-1(7.71e-5)- | 1.856 9e+3(1.96e+3)- | 6.744 6e-1(1.09e-4)≈ | 3.116 6e-1(1.56e-2)+ | 3.315 1e-1(1.22e-1)+ | 6.863 9e-1(9.63e-2)- | 6.753 3e-1(3.54e-3) | |
| LSMOP7 | 100 | 6.491 8e+3(1.93e+3)- | 2.085 7e+1(7.35e+0)- | 1.163 5e+0(2.03e-1)+ | 1.411 6e+0(1.78e-2)≈ | 1.459 5e+0(5.99e-4)- | 1.446 3e+0(8.72e-1)- | 1.376 6e+0(1.15e-1) |
| 500 | 2.124 8e+4(4.82e+3)- | 2.804 1e+4(2.08e+3)- | 1.505 9e+0(8.65e-4)+ | 1.501 3e+0(5.04e-4)+ | 1.602 3e+0(4.19e-1)- | 3.037 3e+0(4.60e-1)- | 1.508 1e+0(1.81e-3) | |
| 1 000 | 2.659 0e+4(5.12e+3)- | 5.300 4e+4(2.90e+3)- | 1.516 2e+0(3.61e-4)- | 1.509 9e+0(3.76e-4)+ | 1.511 6e+0(1.14e-4)+ | 4.010 4e+0(4.88e-1)- | 1.514 8e+0(9.40e-4) | |
| 1 500 | 2.853 9e+4(4.58e+3)- | 6.568 5e+4(3.04e+3)- | 1.519 5e+0(2.34e-4)- | 1.512 4e+0(2.85e-4)+ | 1.791 7e+0(6.62e-1)- | 4.741 0e+0(5.64e-1)- | 1.517 9e+0(2.52e-3) | |
| 2 000 | 2.974 5e+4(4.77e+3)- | 7.195 7e+4(2.37e+3)- | 1.521 3e+0(1.38e-4)- | 1.513 8e+0(2.00e-4)+ | 1.514 3e+0(1.40e-4)+ | 6.914 1e+0(7.98e-1)- | 1.518 4e+0(9.06e-4) | |
| LSMOP8 | 100 | 5.391 1e+0(1.19e+0)- | 8.463 2e-2(3.83e-3)- | 2.892 3e-1(1.16e-1)- | 1.968 1e-1(1.83e-1)- | 7.420 9e-1(1.11e-16)- | 4.965 9e-2(1.15e-2)≈ | 5.119 6e-2(1.39e-2) |
| 500 | 7.852 2e+0(4.60e-1)- | 9.950 7e+0(3.29e-1)- | 7.112 7e-1(6.82e-2)- | 7.420 9e-1(1.11e-16)- | 7.420 9e-1(1.11e-16)- | 1.824 3e-1(3.53e-2)+ | 3.005 2e-1(3.55e-2) | |
| 1 000 | 9.153 6e+0(6.59e-1)- | 1.434 3e+1(3.98e-1)- | 7.414 4e-1(1.94e-3)- | 7.420 9e-1(1.11e-16)- | 7.420 9e-1(1.11e-16)- | 9.295 6e-1(2.02e-1)- | 7.008 3e-1(4.48e-2) | |
| 1 500 | 9.944 2e+0(5.79e-1)- | 1.639 5e+1(3.79e-1)- | 7.420 9e-1(1.11e-16)+ | 7.420 9e-1(1.11e-16)+ | 7.420 9e-1(1.11e-16)+ | 1.735 5e+0(6.65e-1)- | 7.436 0e-1(2.46e-3) | |
| 2 000 | 1.012 2e+1(5.59e-1)- | 1.750 2e+1(2.61e-1)- | 7.420 9e-1(1.11e-16)- | 7.420 9e-1(1.11e-16)- | 7.421 3e-1(1.79e-4)- | 2.419 5e+0(4.61e-1)- | 7.423 8e-1(6.49e-4) | |
| LSMOP9 | 100 | 1.006 2e+1(4.35e+0)- | 3.191 0e-1(2.88e-2)+ | 8.100 4e-1(1.11e-16)- | 8.100 4e-1(1.11e-16)- | 8.836 3e-1(2.22e-1)- | 1.124 4e+0(1.37e+0)- | 8.099 9e-1(0.00e+0) |
| 500 | 2.338 7e+1(4.52e+0)- | 2.246 9e+1(1.39e+0)- | 8.100 4e-1(1.11e-16)- | 8.019 8e-1(1.98e-2)- | 7.721 7e-1(1.62e-1)- | 8.997 9e-1(2.50e-1)- | 8.013 2e-1(4.60e-3) | |
| 1 000 | 2.788 2e+1(3.71e+0)- | 3.914 5e+1(2.21e+0)- | 8.095 6e-1(2.41e-4)- | 8.003 1e-1(7.13e-3)- | 7.915 9e-1(5.15e-2)- | 8.628 8e-1(2.35e-2)- | 7.781 1e-1(3.79e-2) | |
| 1 500 | 3.095 6e+1(3.81e+0)- | 4.723 8e+1(1.32e+0)- | 8.092 0e-1(4.21e-4)- | 7.983 4e-1(1.50e-2)- | 7.665 3e-1(8.64e-2)- | 9.388 3e-1(4.78e-2)- | 7.635 4e-1(4.21e-2) | |
| 2 000 | 3.269 0e+1(3.42e+0)- | 5.112 6e+1(1.31e+0)- | 8.089 1e-1(4.74e-4)- | 8.007 8e-1(5.67e-3)- | 7.743 1e-1(6.01e-2)- | 1.615 6e+0(1.48e+0)- | 7.781 9e-1(3.35e-2) | |
| +/-/≈ | 0/45/0 | 1/44/0 | 6/37/2 | 13/29/3 | 11/33/1 | 3/40/2 | ||
Table 2
Statistical results of IGD values obtained by comparison algorithms and MRADG on tri-objective LSMOP1~LSMOP9 test problems
测试 问题 | 目标 维度 | CCGDE3 | MOEA/DVA | LCSA | LSMOF | FLEA | LERD | MRADG |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| LSMOP1 | 100 | 5.125 2e+0(1.57e+0)- | 8.016 3e-2(4.27e-3)+ | 2.262 5e-1(7.15e-3)+ | 3.884 5e-1(5.39e-2)- | 6.306 3e-1(1.82e-1)- | 2.588 9e-1(5.82e-2)+ | 2.914 8e-1(1.86e-2) |
| 500 | 8.736 7e+0(1.14e+0)- | 4.846 0e+0(3.67e-1)- | 4.078 8e-1(7.13e-2)+ | 6.730 0e-1(5.12e-2)- | 6.898 1e-1(1.44e-1)- | 9.639 5e-1(2.88e-1)- | 5.465 3e-1(4.70e-2) | |
| 1 000 | 9.145 0e+0(9.21e-1)- | 7.703 9e+0(2.28e-1)- | 5.944 3e-1(3.97e-2)- | 7.140 8e-1(1.25e-2)- | 7.511 3e-1(1.38e-1)- | 1.418 0e+0(2.17e-1)- | 5.798 3e-1(5.01e-2) | |
| 1 500 | 9.386 0e+0(1.25e+0)- | 9.027 8e+0(2.83e-1)- | 6.490 9e-1(4.56e-2)- | 7.246 7e-1(1.19e-2)- | 7.272 4e-1(1.65e-1)- | 1.420 4e+0(2.24e-1)- | 6.175 0e-1(4.98e-2) | |
| 2 000 | 9.584 8e+0(1.08e+0)- | 9.807 0e+0(2.59e-1)- | 7.079 4e-1(3.27e-2)- | 7.297 2e-1(1.27e-2)- | 8.399 9e-1(1.71e-1)- | 1.452 4e+0(2.18e-1)- | 6.440 9e-1(4.72e-2) | |
| LSMOP2 | 100 | 2.251 1e-1(5.89e-3)- | 1.483 1e-1(3.94e-3)+ | 2.229 6e-1(1.37e-2)- | 2.001 3e-1(3.98e-3)- | 1.697 6e-1(1.72e-2)≈ | 1.720 6e-1(5.63e-3)≈ | 1.683 1e-1(1.14e-2) |
| 500 | 8.216 2e-2(5.08e-3)- | 7.887 6e-2(2.65e-3)- | 8.834 0e-2(2.96e-3)- | 7.508 6e-2(1.94e-3)- | 8.288 5e-2(4.80e-3)- | 6.929 1e-2(1.51e-3)≈ | 6.948 5e-2(5.06e-3) | |
| 1 000 | 6.415 8e-2(4.74e-3)- | 6.410 7e-2(2.45e-3)- | 7.248 0e-2(4.19e-3)- | 6.082 1e-2(1.72e-3)≈ | 6.967 5e-2(3.78e-3)- | 5.388 6e-2(3.07e-4)+ | 6.095 3e-2(2.61e-3) | |
| 1 500 | 5.961 2e-2(4.13e-3)≈ | 6.129 6e-2(3.03e-3)≈ | 6.744 9e-2(3.35e-3)- | 5.675 8e-2(1.72e-3)+ | 6.745 1e-2(3.41e-3)- | 4.901 8e-2(2.17e-4)+ | 6.184 4e-2(4.85e-3) | |
| 2 000 | 5.612 2e-2(3.10e-3)≈ | 5.955 7e-2(4.34e-3)≈ | 6.483 8e-2(4.30e-3)- | 5.506 1e-2(1.44e-3)+ | 6.477 5e-2(3.23e-3)- | 4.700 2e-2(2.11e-4)+ | 5.842 0e-2(3.64e-3) | |
| LSMOP3 | 100 | 1.401 3e+1(2.23e+0)- | 1.596 4e+0(2.51e-1)- | 4.889 0e-1(1.31e-1)+ | 8.369 5e-1(3.11e-2)≈ | 8.593 6e-1(5.90e-3)- | 1.267 6e+0(9.59e-1)≈ | 8.299 9e-1(4.10e-2) |
| 500 | 2.101 9e+1(2.96e+0)- | 1.690 7e+2(1.19e+2)- | 7.587 4e-1(2.95e-2)+ | 8.607 1e-1(2.21e-5)≈ | 1.113 1e+0(7.71e-1)≈ | 9.599 1e+0(3.94e-1)- | 8.521 7e-1(1.89e-2) | |
| 1 000 | 2.036 6e+1(2.93e+0)- | 2.510 3e+2(1.84e+2)- | 8.416 8e-1(4.73e-3)+ | 8.607 1e-1(2.88e-5)+ | 1.597 2e+0(1.30e+0)≈ | 9.772 7e+0(3.98e-1)- | 8.882 4e-1(1.25e-1) | |
| 1 500 | 2.161 3e+1(3.46e+0)- | 2.396 1e+2(2.01e+2)- | 8.607 2e-1(9.29e-6)+ | 8.607 2e-1(0.00e+0)+ | 2.304 7e+0(1.77e+0)≈ | 9.975 4e+0(3.72e-1)- | 8.986 4e-1(1.03e-1) | |
| 2 000 | 2.210 7e+1(4.70e+0)- | 3.213 2e+2(2.59e+2)- | 8.607 2e-1(0.00e+0)+ | 8.607 1e-1(3.27e-5)+ | 1.785 2e+0(1.62e+0)≈ | 9.979 6e+0(2.64e-1)- | 8.966 9e-1(1.20e-1) | |
| LSMOP4 | 100 | 5.576 6e-1(1.14e-2)- | 1.967 4e-1(1.65e-2)+ | 3.135 9e-1(1.51e-2)+ | 3.805 7e-1(9.59e-3)- | 4.165 1e-1(2.45e-2)- | 2.276 0e-1(7.81e-3)+ | 3.430 0e-1(1.83e-2) |
| 500 | 2.121 1e-1(7.37e-3)- | 1.777 7e-1(5.48e-3)- | 2.258 9e-1(5.81e-3)- | 1.800 4e-1(5.69e-3)- | 1.516 7e-1(6.20e-3)- | 1.543 2e-1(7.29e-3)- | 1.322 8e-1(3.45e-3) | |
| 1 000 | 1.302 9e-1(5.01e-3)- | 1.233 3e-1(2.26e-3)- | 1.454 1e-1(3.58e-3)- | 1.156 2e-1(2.89e-3)- | 1.092 1e-1(5.39e-3)- | 1.059 3e-1(3.45e-3)- | 8.780 3e-2(2.40e-3) | |
| 1 500 | 1.021 5e-1(5.32e-3)- | 9.898 2e-2(1.78e-3)- | 1.143 0e-1(3.83e-3)- | 8.995 2e-2(3.14e-3)- | 9.197 3e-2(4.99e-3)- | 8.344 1e-2(2.30e-3)- | 7.352 8e-2(2.91e-3) | |
| 2 000 | 8.610 8e-2(5.98e-3)- | 8.707 9e-2(4.03e-3)- | 9.777 3e-2(4.08e-3)- | 7.834 3e-2(2.00e-3)- | 8.145 9e-2(5.08e-3)- | 7.226 7e-2(1.27e-3)- | 6.749 0e-2(3.85e-3) | |
| LSMOP5 | 100 | 7.788 8e+0(2.29e+0)- | 1.699 9e-1(1.01e-2)- | 4.223 5e-1(5.98e-2)- | 3.459 1e-1(2.45e-2)- | 9.515 9e-1(2.74e-1)- | 3.583 5e-1(9.82e-4)- | 1.593 5e-1(5.00e-2) |
| 500 | 1.456 2e+1(2.18e+0)- | 9.368 4e+0(4.67e-1)- | 5.409 6e-1(3.76e-5)- | 5.499 5e-1(1.22e-1)- | 1.134 4e+0(3.66e-1)- | 1.004 8e+0(8.06e-1)- | 4.696 7e-1(2.29e-2) | |
| 1 000 | 1.672 0e+1(2.15e+0)- | 1.373 7e+1(6.32e-1)- | 5.410 8e-1(3.88e-5)- | 5.731 0e-1(1.19e-1)- | 1.115 1e+0(3.17e-1)- | 2.023 5e+0(1.07e+0)- | 5.244 2e-1(1.53e-2) | |
| 1 500 | 1.679 3e+1(2.21e+0)- | 1.595 4e+1(6.16e-1)- | 5.410 7e-1(3.32e-5)- | 5.791 3e-1(1.22e-1)- | 1.075 9e+0(3.55e-1)- | 2.355 1e+0(9.02e-1)- | 5.386 8e-1(4.08e-3) | |
| 2 000 | 1.784 9e+1(1.98e+0)- | 1.713 1e+1(4.46e-1)- | 5.410 6e-1(3.77e-5)- | 5.797 3e-1(1.22e-1)- | 9.024 9e-1(3.26e-1)- | 3.157 7e+0(3.92e-1)- | 5.392 6e-1(4.68e-3) | |
| LSMOP6 | 100 | 1.640 8e+3(1.33e+3)- | 7.994 4e+0(2.41e+0)- | 9.865 0e-1(5.99e-3)≈ | 7.914 9e-1(1.26e-1)+ | 4.965 5e+1(1.90e+2)≈ | 1.046 5e+0(4.98e-1)+ | 1.030 1e+0(1.46e-1) |
| 500 | 2.173 5e+4(5.90e+3)- | 1.311 5e+4(2.29e+3)- | 1.280 8e+0(1.17e-3)+ | 1.241 7e+0(1.03e-1)≈ | 1.243 7e+0(2.65e-1)+ | 4.172 4e+0(4.16e+0)- | 1.292 9e+0(2.04e-3) | |
| 1 000 | 2.696 8e+4(8.19e+3)- | 2.393 4e+4(4.21e+3)- | 1.310 9e+0(7.78e-4)+ | 1.244 5e+0(1.39e-1)≈ | 1.278 2e+0(2.44e-1)+ | 5.631 5e+1(1.13e+2)- | 1.313 8e+0(2.15e-3) | |
| 1 500 | 2.604 6e+4(5.51e+3)- | 2.839 5e+4(3.84e+3)- | 1.319 9e+0(6.45e-4)≈ | 1.221 5e+0(1.70e-1)≈ | 2.624 4e+1(7.88e+1)≈ | 4.695 6e+1(3.41e+1)- | 1.320 7e+0(3.86e-3) | |
| 2 000 | 2.813 2e+4(5.85e+3)- | 3.414 9e+4(5.29e+3)- | 1.324 2e+0(2.40e-4)- | 1.122 6e+0(2.36e-1)+ | 9.742 5e+0(3.68e+1)+ | 1.351 4e+2(1.24e+2)- | 1.323 4e+0(1.55e-3) | |
| LSMOP7 | 100 | 2.903 2e+0(3.05e-1)- | 3.398 6e+0(3.29e+0)- | 1.007 2e+0(3.80e-2)- | 9.117 9e-1(6.14e-2)- | 1.731 1e+0(4.33e-1)- | 8.568 2e-1(8.43e-2)- | 8.340 2e-1(3.64e-2) |
| 500 | 1.306 0e+0(1.48e-2)- | 1.041 0e+3(8.05e+2)- | 9.014 2e-1(5.87e-3)- | 8.225 0e-1(6.74e-2)≈ | 9.443 6e-1(1.39e-1)≈ | 9.670 7e-1(1.01e-1)- | 8.552 4e-1(2.60e-2) | |
| 1 000 | 1.104 9e+0(4.74e-3)- | 1.403 7e+3(9.57e+2)- | 8.680 8e-1(1.11e-3)- | 8.162 0e-1(1.05e-1)- | 9.418 7e-1(9.05e-2)- | 9.744 0e-1(7.76e-2)- | 8.096 4e-1(5.76e-2) | |
| 1 500 | 1.044 7e+0(2.41e-3)- | 1.478 8e+3(9.75e+2)- | 8.565 6e-1(5.68e-4)- | 8.040 3e-1(9.58e-2)≈ | 9.659 6e-1(1.59e-2)- | 9.848 4e-1(5.18e-2)- | 8.259 3e-1(3.47e-2) | |
| 2 000 | 1.017 5e+0(1.56e-3)- | 2.068 6e+3(1.60e+3)- | 8.511 0e-1(5.08e-4)- | 7.863 6e-1(9.85e-2)+ | 9.731 2e-1(2.09e-2)- | 9.799 8e-1(2.77e-2)- | 8.216 8e-1(3.70e-2) | |
| LSMOP8 | 100 | 9.793 7e-1(1.02e-1)- | 1.378 6e-1(6.51e-3)+ | 3.546 7e-1(1.87e-2)- | 3.060 1e-1(4.04e-2)- | 4.030 5e-1(1.43e-1)- | 3.498 1e-1(3.13e-2)- | 2.260 8e-1(4.34e-2) |
| 500 | 9.612 5e-1(2.34e-2)- | 6.585 0e-1(5.57e-2)- | 3.581 1e-1(8.29e-3)- | 2.890 7e-1(5.67e-2)≈ | 5.484 7e-1(3.27e-2)- | 3.009 9e-1(5.46e-2)≈ | 2.793 6e-1(4.18e-2) | |
| 1 000 | 8.973 9e-1(9.10e-2)- | 6.796 7e-1(6.06e-2)- | 3.331 3e-1(2.22e-2)- | 2.513 6e-1(3.05e-2)- | 5.583 3e-1(1.00e-1)- | 2.463 1e-1(3.59e-2)- | 2.355 5e-1(1.51e-2) | |
| 1 500 | 9.276 4e-1(6.40e-2)- | 6.950 0e-1(6.94e-2)- | 3.331 1e-1(2.71e-2)- | 2.466 2e-1(3.45e-2)- | 7.144 6e-1(1.66e-1)- | 2.741 8e-1(1.03e-1)- | 2.314 4e-1(5.86e-3) | |
| 2 000 | 9.077 5e-1(7.43e-2)- | 6.868 8e-1(5.56e-2)- | 3.108 4e-1(2.98e-2)- | 2.338 1e-1(4.09e-3)- | 8.223 4e-1(1.54e-1)- | 4.139 5e-1(1.51e-1)- | 2.302 3e-1(7.54e-3) | |
| LSMOP9 | 100 | 3.045 3e+1(9.57e+0)- | 6.146 8e-1(5.08e-2)≈ | 1.443 0e+0(2.85e-1)- | 1.479 1e+0(1.40e-1)- | 1.557 5e+0(8.53e-2)- | 1.481 5e+0(1.46e+0)- | 8.610 5e-1(2.75e-1) |
| 500 | 6.125 5e+1(7.57e+0)- | 5.487 8e+1(2.92e+0)- | 1.537 9e+0(2.22e-16)- | 1.498 6e+0(1.18e-1)- | 1.303 6e+0(3.58e-1)- | 1.378 2e+0(1.72e-1)- | 1.081 4e+0(1.64e-1) | |
| 1 000 | 7.260 4e+1(8.20e+0)- | 9.518 9e+1(4.50e+0)- | 1.537 9e+0(2.22e-16)- | 1.184 6e+0(1.18e-1)- | 1.474 6e+0(2.09e-1)- | 1.636 5e+0(1.42e-1)- | 1.080 9e+0(1.65e-1) | |
| 1 500 | 7.787 9e+1(9.90e+0)- | 1.154 1e+2(2.24e+0)- | 1.490 4e+0(2.07e-1)- | 1.282 5e+0(1.87e-1)- | 1.205 0e+0(4.19e-1)- | 2.418 1e+0(1.38e+0)- | 1.082 1e+0(1.64e-1) | |
| 2 000 | 8.081 4e+1(8.52e+0)- | 1.245 9e+2(3.25e+0)- | 1.537 9e+0(2.22e-16)- | 1.203 9e+0(1.40e-1)- | 1.338 6e+0(3.68e-1)- | 3.472 8e+0(1.75e+0)- | 1.084 2e+0(1.66e-1) | |
| +/-/≈ | 0/43/2 | 4/38/3 | 10/33/2 | 8/28/9 | 3/34/8 | 6/35/4 | ||
Table 3
Statistical results of IGD values (mean and standard deviation) obtained by comparison algorithms and MRADG on tri-objective IMF1~IMF10 test problems
| 测试问题 | 目标维度 | CCGDE3 | MOEADVA | LCSA | LSMOF | FLEA | LERD | MRADG |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| IMF1 | 100 | 3.491 1e+0(8.21e-1)- | 6.291 2e-2(5.99e-3)- | 2.564 9e-1(7.69e-2)- | 4.621 5e-1(1.46e-2)- | 3.205 1e-1(1.07e-1)- | 5.622 9e-3(2.08e-4)+ | 8.020 2e-3(8.16e-4) |
| 500 | 6.126 8e+0(5.54e-1)- | 6.384 5e+0(4.71e-1)- | 5.296 6e-1(4.98e-3)- | 5.368 5e-1(5.40e-3)- | 3.829 8e-1(1.01e-1)- | 3.912 8e-1(1.75e-2)- | 2.165 8e-1(2.09e-2) | |
| 1 000 | 6.863 5e+0(5.60e-1)- | 1.021 5e+1(4.37e-1)- | 5.706 3e-1(1.91e-3)- | 5.505 0e-1(8.44e-3)- | 4.995 3e-1(1.57e-1)- | 4.722 1e-1(1.05e-2)- | 3.282 4e-1(3.09e-2) | |
| 1 500 | 7.088 9e+0(5.90e-1)- | 1.217 3e+1(2.83e-1)- | 5.815 1e-1(1.69e-3)- | 5.560 9e-1(5.96e-3)- | 3.871 6e-1(1.23e-1)≈ | 5.399 5e-1(7.97e-2)- | 3.878 3e-1(2.18e-2) | |
| 2 000 | 7.558 9e+0(5.72e-1)- | 1.324 6e+1(4.10e-1)- | 5.861 4e-1(1.06e-3)- | 5.579 1e-1(4.37e-3)- | 4.171 0e-1(1.49e-1)- | 6.525 5e-1(1.31e-1)- | 4.124 7e-1(2.36e-2) | |
| IMF2 | 100 | 5.419 4e+0(1.02e+0)- | 9.244 3e-2(1.03e-2)+ | 6.094 9e-1(0.00e+0)+ | 6.094 9e-1(0.00e+0)+ | 6.094 9e-1(0.00e+0)+ | 6.753 1e-1(2.87e-1)+ | 6.094 9e-1(0.00e+0) |
| 500 | 8.554 4e+0(6.90e-1)- | 8.761 2e+0(4.30e-1)- | 6.094 9e-1(0.00e+0)≈ | 6.094 9e-1(0.00e+0)+ | 6.094 9e-1(0.00e+0)+ | 6.056 4e-1(3.71e-3)+ | 6.094 9e-1(2.17e-8) | |
| 1 000 | 9.782 5e+0(7.25e-1)- | 1.342 5e+1(5.09e-1)- | 6.094 9e-1(0.00e+0)+ | 6.094 9e-1(0.00e+0)+ | 6.094 9e-1(2.30e-5)+ | 5.807 5e-1(7.69e-3)+ | 6.094 9e-1(1.54e-8) | |
| 1 500 | 1.003 3e+1(6.47e-1)- | 1.578 1e+1(4.54e-1)- | 6.094 9e-1(0.00e+0)+ | 6.094 9e-1(0.00e+0)+ | 6.102 5e-1(1.73e-3)+ | 5.949 1e-1(1.73e-2)+ | 6.099 1e-1(1.29e-3) | |
| 2 000 | 1.067 0e+1(7.11e-1)- | 1.707 2e+1(4.83e-1)- | 6.094 9e-1(0.00e+0)+ | 6.094 9e-1(0.00e+0)+ | 6.152 7e-1(1.76e-2)≈ | 6.938 9e-1(1.31e-1)- | 6.100 4e-1(1.42e-3) | |
| IMF3 | 100 | 5.558 0e+0(1.01e+0)- | 1.723 6e-1(2.38e-2)- | 4.911 3e-3(1.58e-4)+ | 6.745 5e-3(6.72e-4)- | 2.731 6e-2(4.44e-2)- | 4.039 5e-3(2.31e-4)+ | 5.965 5e-3(9.25e-4) |
| 500 | 8.439 4e+0(7.72e-1)- | 8.915 7e+0(5.24e-1)- | 1.071 3e-2(3.35e-4)- | 1.000 5e-2(7.34e-4)- | 1.773 0e-2(1.88e-2)- | 1.739 1e-2(5.15e-3)- | 8.469 8e-3(1.02e-3) | |
| 1 000 | 9.500 6e+0(6.22e-1)- | 1.373 1e+1(5.56e-1)- | 1.746 2e-2(3.04e-4)- | 1.199 3e-2(7.30e-4)- | 3.469 3e-2(4.12e-2)- | 5.378 5e-2(1.87e-2)- | 9.533 9e-3(1.01e-3) | |
| 1 500 | 1.028 5e+1(7.58e-1)- | 1.582 4e+1(4.83e-1)- | 2.054 2e-2(2.50e-4)- | 1.293 5e-2(1.24e-3)- | 2.114 6e-2(2.84e-2)- | 1.144 5e-1(3.20e-2)- | 9.792 0e-3(6.45e-4) | |
| 2 000 | 1.087 6e+1(7.77e-1)- | 1.713 3e+1(3.68e-1)- | 2.204 6e-2(2.29e-4)- | 1.370 0e-2(1.88e-3)- | 2.958 8e-2(2.29e-2)- | 3.231 3e-1(2.22e-1)- | 1.022 3e-2(7.62e-4) | |
| IMF4 | 100 | 5.895 2e+1(9.98e+0)- | 5.644 1e-1(9.07e-2)- | 5.375 1e-1(1.52e-2)- | 5.417 9e-1(1.38e-3)- | 8.712 7e-1(1.50e-1)- | 8.788 2e-2(2.22e-2)+ | 1.949 5e-1(4.41e-2) |
| 500 | 5.201 5e+2(4.80e+1)- | 4.847 3e+2(2.50e+1)- | 5.409 1e-1(2.22e-5)+ | 5.617 2e-1(8.81e-2)- | 9.273 7e-1(8.09e-2)- | 5.594 5e-1(7.39e-2)- | 5.412 4e-1(3.65e-4) | |
| 1 000 | 1.192 9e+3(9.52e+1)- | 1.464 9e+3(4.03e+1)- | 5.409 2e-1(3.06e-5)+ | 5.816 8e-1(1.21e-1)≈ | 9.257 6e-1(8.79e-2)- | 4.140 0e+1(2.80e+1)- | 5.414 6e-1(5.78e-4) | |
| 1 500 | 1.875 1e+3(1.59e+2)- | 2.607 7e+3(6.92e+1)- | 5.409 2e-1(1.16e-5)+ | 6.299 0e-1(1.61e-1)≈ | 2.424 7e+0(3.50e+0)- | 1.251 7e+2(6.61e+1)- | 5.415 1e-1(4.20e-4) | |
| 2 000 | 2.712 1e+3(2.10e+2)- | 3.726 1e+3(7.76e+1)- | 5.409 1e-1(1.60e-5)+ | 6.171 1e-1(1.51e-1)≈ | 3.249 5e+1(5.62e+1)- | 2.646 8e+2(1.58e+2)- | 5.414 6e-1(6.96e-4) | |
| IMF5 | 100 | 1.821 8e-1(1.20e-2)- | 2.094 0e-2(1.14e-3)- | 3.255 3e-2(2.05e-3)- | 2.592 3e-2(2.50e-3)- | 1.282 1e-1(1.45e-2)- | 5.728 8e-3(2.24e-4)+ | 1.046 1e-2(4.51e-4) |
| 500 | 2.520 4e-1(1.08e-2)- | 2.011 3e-1(2.15e-3)- | 7.938 5e-2(2.70e-3)- | 4.488 0e-2(7.58e-4)- | 1.421 6e-1(4.17e-3)- | 4.236 0e-2(7.87e-3)- | 3.119 6e-2(1.19e-3) | |
| 1 000 | 2.697 0e-1(1.15e-2)- | 2.632 7e-1(3.21e-3)- | 1.037 5e-1(4.12e-3)- | 4.621 4e-2(5.16e-4)- | 1.408 6e-1(5.20e-3)- | 7.712 0e-2(1.34e-2)- | 4.026 4e-2(9.37e-4) | |
| 1 500 | 2.796 1e-1(1.45e-2)- | 2.914 5e-1(2.61e-3)- | 1.144 3e-1(2.28e-3)- | 4.668 5e-2(5.15e-4)- | 1.293 1e-1(2.01e-2)- | 9.177 7e-2(1.42e-2)- | 4.369 9e-2(5.77e-4) | |
| 2 000 | 2.745 0e-1(1.26e-2)- | 3.079 9e-1(3.20e-3)- | 1.251 4e-1(9.78e-3)- | 4.672 0e-2(3.17e-4)- | 1.330 6e-1(1.64e-2)- | 8.641 1e-2(9.92e-3)- | 4.486 3e-2(4.64e-4) | |
| IMF6 | 100 | 2.992 8e-1(3.08e-2)- | 3.654 6e-2(1.87e-3)- | 5.585 9e-2(3.54e-3)- | 6.347 2e-2(6.35e-3)- | 1.188 3e-1(4.64e-3)- | 4.221 0e-2(7.36e-3)- | 2.585 5e-2(3.91e-3) |
| 500 | 4.285 1e-1(2.49e-2)- | 3.321 5e-1(4.57e-3)- | 1.479 2e-1(1.06e-2)- | 9.357 6e-2(6.10e-3)- | 1.263 4e-1(3.98e-3)- | 1.362 1e-1(3.60e-2)- | 6.719 5e-2(3.25e-3) | |
| 1 000 | 4.509 7e-1(1.77e-2)- | 4.492 3e-1(6.46e-3)- | 1.521 0e-1(2.37e-2)- | 9.700 1e-2(6.32e-3)- | 1.268 7e-1(3.83e-3)- | 1.786 0e-1(4.46e-2)- | 8.217 3e-2(1.42e-3) | |
| 1 500 | 4.612 0e-1(2.06e-2)- | 5.093 7e-1(7.11e-3)- | 1.429 9e-1(2.43e-2)- | 9.882 6e-2(7.26e-3)- | 1.259 7e-1(4.38e-3)- | 1.786 2e-1(4.47e-2)- | 8.732 0e-2(1.18e-3) | |
| 2 000 | 4.735 6e-1(2.96e-2)- | 5.424 5e-1(6.34e-3)- | 1.590 0e-1(2.17e-2)- | 1.005 5e-1(6.71e-3)- | 1.241 9e-1(4.05e-3)- | 2.002 8e-1(3.44e-2)- | 9.046 4e-2(8.83e-4) | |
| IMF7 | 100 | 2.890 1e-1(7.84e-3)- | 9.676 9e-2(6.75e-3)- | 5.095 3e-3(2.01e-4)+ | 8.315 7e-3(7.73e-4)- | 2.372 4e-2(1.71e-2)- | 4.870 0e-3(3.02e-4)+ | 7.284 2e-3(9.84e-4) |
| 500 | 3.463 7e-1(8.72e-3)- | 3.420 2e-1(5.04e-3)- | 9.601 7e-3(1.36e-3)+ | 1.648 9e-2(1.13e-3)- | 4.028 8e-2(3.17e-2)- | 1.655 4e-2(1.25e-2)+ | 1.499 7e-2(1.23e-3) | |
| 1 000 | 3.691 2e-1(1.93e-2)- | 4.050 2e-1(3.90e-3)- | 1.434 6e-2(1.19e-3)+ | 2.139 8e-2(1.61e-3)- | 4.653 8e-2(4.18e-2)- | 2.150 1e-1(5.10e-2)- | 1.758 0e-2(1.00e-3) | |
| 1 500 | 3.766 1e-1(1.82e-2)- | 4.432 8e-1(4.99e-3)- | 1.730 1e-2(1.33e-3)+ | 2.244 9e-2(2.01e-3)- | 3.762 0e-2(2.70e-2)- | 2.290 0e-1(3.25e-2)- | 1.921 0e-2(1.35e-3) | |
| 2 000 | 3.709 4e-1(1.19e-2)- | 4.677 6e-1(4.19e-3)- | 1.875 6e-2(1.11e-3)≈ | 2.385 2e-2(1.92e-3)- | 5.650 5e-2(3.02e-2)- | 2.483 8e-1(3.42e-2)- | 1.966 6e-2(1.79e-3) | |
| IMF8 | 100 | 2.551 6e+0(5.39e-1)- | 2.896 7e-1(1.44e-2)+ | 3.571 7e-1(1.00e-4)- | 3.561 7e-1(4.96e-4)+ | 9.325 0e-1(5.85e-2)- | 2.503 3e-1(9.74e-2)≈ | 3.566 7e-1(2.60e-4) |
| 500 | 1.751 5e+1(3.31e+0)- | 1.085 1e+1(5.75e-1)- | 3.572 1e-1(1.87e-5)- | 3.571 8e-1(4.93e-5)- | 8.519 8e-1(1.28e-1)- | 5.204 5e-1(1.72e-1)- | 3.571 7e-1(3.30e-5) | |
| 1 000 | 3.852 3e+1(6.87e+0)- | 3.513 5e+1(1.10e+0)- | 3.572 1e-1(1.77e-5)- | 3.571 9e-1(3.65e-5)- | 8.519 8e-1(1.28e-1)- | 8.238 1e-1(2.93e-1)- | 3.571 6e-1(1.52e-4) | |
| 1 500 | 6.018 9e+1(1.01e+1)- | 6.195 1e+1(1.37e+0)- | 3.572 0e-1(2.14e-5)≈ | 3.572 0e-1(2.19e-5)≈ | 8.251 3e-1(1.34e-1)- | 1.790 3e+0(7.61e-1)- | 3.572 0e-1(2.51e-5) | |
| 2 000 | 8.084 3e+1(1.56e+1)- | 8.966 2e+1(1.76e+0)- | 3.572 0e-1(2.02e-5)≈ | 3.572 2e-1(1.68e-5)- | 7.848 7e-1(1.31e-1)- | 3.827 7e+0(1.42e+0)- | 3.572 0e-1(1.97e-5) | |
| IMF9 | 100 | 4.437 0e-1(3.51e-2)- | 1.516 7e-1(4.72e-2)- | 1.588 1e-2(3.53e-4)- | 1.386 2e-2(1.46e-3)- | 6.213 3e-2(9.70e-2)- | 6.662 1e-3(2.63e-4)- | 5.533 6e-3(3.47e-4) |
| 500 | 6.136 7e-1(9.19e-3)- | 5.930 3e-1(7.22e-3)- | 7.852 7e-2(1.37e-2)- | 4.841 2e-2(4.89e-3)- | 7.870 1e-2(1.15e-1)- | 4.937 2e-2(4.74e-3)- | 6.280 4e-3(3.33e-4) | |
| 1 000 | 7.227 8e-1(1.19e-2)- | 7.845 6e-1(6.63e-3)- | 2.120 8e-1(7.44e-2)- | 8.159 5e-2(1.28e-2)- | 1.035 4e-1(1.03e-1)- | 1.270 8e-1(2.34e-2)- | 6.482 0e-3(2.27e-4) | |
| 1 500 | 8.271 7e-1(1.18e-2)- | 9.900 6e-1(1.30e-2)- | 4.060 8e-1(4.90e-3)- | 1.492 0e-1(4.27e-2)- | 1.372 7e-1(1.19e-1)- | 1.985 4e-1(4.03e-2)- | 6.883 8e-3(2.60e-4) | |
| 2 000 | 9.477 4e-1(1.53e-2)- | 1.188 9e+0(2.44e-2)- | 4.296 8e-1(8.48e-3)- | 2.324 8e-1(7.47e-2)- | 2.244 2e-1(2.17e-1)- | 2.555 6e-1(4.42e-2)- | 7.607 9e-3(2.76e-4) | |
| IMF10 | 100 | 5.275 6e+2(7.81e+1)- | 9.967 0e+1(4.67e+0)- | 8.254 5e-1(4.21e-5)+ | 8.254 9e-1(2.21e-5)+ | 1.412 1e+2(1.82e+2)≈ | 2.436 4e+2(3.75e+2)≈ | 4.589 8e+1(1.65e+1) |
| 500 | 4.124 4e+3(2.06e+2)- | 3.390 7e+3(3.50e+1)- | 8.347 4e-1(4.08e-3)+ | 8.373 1e-1(4.08e-3)+ | 2.476 8e+2(6.19e+2)+ | 1.426 9e+3(6.85e+2)- | 2.335 5e+2(5.61e+1) | |
| 1 000 | 9.224 3e+3(4.69e+2)- | 9.280 3e+3(1.12e+2)- | 8.379 3e-1(3.23e-3)+ | 8.389 5e-1(2.71e-3)+ | 9.241 6e+2(1.28e+3)≈ | 1.966 5e+3(1.15e+3)- | 4.291 9e+2(1.45e+2) | |
| 1 500 | 1.427 9e+4(6.13e+2)- | 1.547 0e+4(1.40e+2)- | 8.391 2e-1(2.36e-3)+ | 8.403 0e-1(1.11e-16)+ | 6.784 1e+2(1.16e+3)+ | 2.495 1e+3(1.11e+3)- | 6.970 1e+2(4.18e+1) | |
| 2 000 | 1.986 8e+4(5.96e+2)- | 2.187 1e+4(1.91e+2)- | 8.395 0e-1(1.92e-3)+ | 8.403 0e-1(1.11e-16)+ | 1.123 0e+3(3.46e+3)+ | 3.026 2e+3(9.84e+2)- | 9.186 9e+2(4.61e+1) | |
| +/-/≈ | 0/50/0 | 2/48/0 | 18/28/4 | 11/35/4 | 7/39/4 | 10/38/2 | ||
| [1] | Cao Bin, Zhao Jianwei, Yang Po, et al. Distributed Parallel Cooperative Coevolutionary Multi-objective Large-scale Immune Algorithm for Deployment of Wireless Sensor Networks[J]. Future Generation Computer Systems, 2018, 82: 256-267. |
| [2] | Zhang Xingyi, Zhou Kefei, Pan Hebin, et al. A Network Reduction-based Multiobjective Evolutionary Algorithm for Community Detection in Large-scale Complex Networks[J]. IEEE Transactions on Cybernetics, 2020, 50(2): 703-716. |
| [3] | Gan Xiaohui, Liu Jing. A Multi-objective Evolutionary Algorithm for Emergency Logistics Scheduling in Large-scale Disaster Relief[C]//2017 IEEE Congress on Evolutionary Computation (CEC). Piscataway: IEEE, 2017: 51-58. |
| [4] | Luis Miguel Antonio, A Coello Coello Carlos. Use of Cooperative Coevolution for Solving Large Scale Multiobjective Optimization Problems[C]//2013 IEEE Congress on Evolutionary Computation. Piscataway: IEEE, 2013: 2758-2765. |
| [5] | Liu Jin, Liu Ruochen, Zhang Xilong. Recursive Grouping and Dynamic Resource Allocation Method for Large-scale Multi-objective Optimization Problem[J]. Applied Soft Computing, 2022, 130: 109651. |
| [6] | Madani Amirali, Engelbrecht Andries, Ombuki-Berman Beatrice. Cooperative Coevolutionary Multi-guide Particle Swarm Optimization Algorithm for Large-scale Multi-objective Optimization Problems[J]. Swarm and Evolutionary Computation, 2023, 78: 101262. |
| [7] | Tian Ye, Si Langchun, Zhang Xingyi, et al. Evolutionary Large-scale Multi-objective Optimization: A Survey[J]. ACM Computing Surveys, 2021, 54(8): 174. |
| [8] | Ma Xiaoliang, Liu Fang, Qi Yutao, et al. A Multiobjective Evolutionary Algorithm Based on Decision Variable Analyses for Multiobjective Optimization Problems with Large-scale Variables[J]. IEEE Transactions on Evolutionary Computation, 2016, 20(2): 275-298. |
| [9] | Xu Ying, Xu Chong, Zhang Huan, et al. A Multi-population Multi-objective Evolutionary Algorithm Based on the Contribution of Decision Variables to Objectives for Large-scale Multi/Many-objective Optimization[J]. IEEE Transactions on Cybernetics, 2023, 53(11): 6998-7007. |
| [10] | He Cheng, Cheng Ran, Li Lianghao, et al. Large-scale Multiobjective Optimization via Reformulated Decision Variable Analysis[J]. IEEE Transactions on Evolutionary Computation, 2024, 28(1): 47-61. |
| [11] | Zille Heiner, Ishibuchi Hisao, Mostaghim Sanaz, et al. A Framework for Large-scale Multiobjective Optimization Based on Problem Transformation[J]. IEEE Transactions on Evolutionary Computation, 2018, 22(2): 260-275. |
| [12] | He Cheng, Li Lianghao, Tian Ye, et al. Accelerating Large-scale Multiobjective Optimization via Problem Reformulation[J]. IEEE Transactions on Evolutionary Computation, 2019, 23(6): 949-961. |
| [13] | Zhang Maoqing, Li Wuzhao, Zhang Liang, et al. A Pearson Correlation-based Adaptive Variable Grouping Method for Large-scale Multi-objective Optimization[J]. Information Sciences, 2023, 639: 118737. |
| [14] | Tian Ye, Zheng Xiutao, Zhang Xingyi, et al. Efficient Large-scale Multiobjective Optimization Based on a Competitive Swarm Optimizer[J]. IEEE Transactions on Cybernetics, 2020, 50(8): 3696-3708. |
| [15] | Yang Xu, Zou Juan, Yang Shengxiang, et al. A Fuzzy Decision Variables Framework for Large-scale Multiobjective Optimization[J]. IEEE Transactions on Evolutionary Computation, 2023, 27(3): 445-459. |
| [16] | Liu Songbai, Li Jun, Lin Qiuzhen, et al. Learning to Accelerate Evolutionary Search for Large-scale Multiobjective Optimization[J]. IEEE Transactions on Evolutionary Computation, 2023, 27(1): 67-81. |
| [17] | Deb K, Pratap A, Agarwal S, et al. A Fast and Elitist Multiobjective Genetic Algorithm: NSGA-II[J]. IEEE Transactions on Evolutionary Computation, 2002, 6(2): 182-197. |
| [18] | Cheng Ran, Jin Yaochu, Olhofer Markus, et al. Test Problems for Large-scale Multiobjective and Many-objective Optimization[J]. IEEE Transactions on Cybernetics, 2017, 47(12): 4108-4121. |
| [19] | Zhang Qingfu, Li Hui. MOEA/D: A Multiobjective Evolutionary Algorithm Based on Decomposition[J]. IEEE Transactions on Evolutionary Computation, 2007, 11(6): 712-731. |
| [20] | Cheng Ran, Jin Yaochu, Narukawa Kaname, et al. A Multiobjective Evolutionary Algorithm Using Gaussian Process-based Inverse Modeling[J]. IEEE Transactions on Evolutionary Computation, 2015, 19(6): 838-856. |
| [21] | A Coello Coello Carlos, Nareli Cruz Cortés. Solving Multiobjective Optimization Problems Using an Artificial Immune System[J]. Genetic Programming and Evolvable Machines, 2005, 6(2): 163-190. |
| [22] | Zille Heiner. Large-scale Multi-objective Optimisation: New Approaches and a Classification of the State-of-the-art[D]. Magdeburg: Otto von Guericke University Magdeburg, 2019. |
| [23] | Li Lianghao, He Cheng, Cheng Ran, et al. A Fast Sampling Based Evolutionary Algorithm for Million-dimensional Multiobjective Optimization[J]. Swarm and Evolutionary Computation, 2022, 75: 101181. |
| [1] | Liu Wei, Chen Delong, Liu Ze, Wang Rui, Li Kaiwen, Zhang Tao. Optimization of Air Defense and Antimissile Firepower Resource Allocation Based on Adaptive Hybrid Evolution [J]. Journal of System Simulation, 2026, 38(4): 959-973. |
| [2] | Ji Zhicheng, Quan Zhen, Wang Yan. Optimization and Simulation of Adaptive Production Scheduling Based on Hybrid Decision-making Mechanism [J]. Journal of System Simulation, 2025, 37(7): 1791-1803. |
| [3] | Di Jian, Wan Xue, Jiang Limei. Evolutionary Reinforcement Learning Based on Elite Instruction and Random Search [J]. Journal of System Simulation, 2025, 37(11): 2877-2887. |
| [4] | Zhang Wenqiang, Wang Xiaomeng, Zhang Xiaoxiao, Zhang Guohui. Hybrid Evolutionary Multi-objective Optimization Algorithm for Vehicle Routing Problem with Simultaneous Delivery and Pickup [J]. Journal of System Simulation, 2024, 36(8): 1914-1928. |
| [5] | Sun Xin, Xing Lining, Wang Rui, Wang Ling, Shi Jianmai, Luo Tianyu. Air Defense Missile Weapon Target Assignment Based on Multi-objective Evolutionary Algorithm [J]. Journal of System Simulation, 2024, 36(6): 1298-1308. |
| [6] | Zhang Hu, Zhang Heng, Huang Zilu, Wang Zhe, Fu Qingpo, Peng Jin, Wang Feng. Mixed-variable Particle Swarm Optimization Algorithm Based on Competitive Coevolution [J]. Journal of System Simulation, 2024, 36(4): 844-858. |
| [7] | Hongcai Ouyang, Dinghui Wu, Junyan Fan, Jing Wang. Multi-media Energy Planning Optimization of Steel Based on Improved MOEA/D [J]. Journal of System Simulation, 2023, 35(3): 568-578. |
| [8] | Jiawei Zhou, Xin Du, Youcong Ni, Hu Zhang, Hao Zhang, Haoran Ni, Feng Wang. Uniform Experimental Design with Constrained Region Based on Fruit Fly Algorithm [J]. Journal of System Simulation, 2023, 35(1): 110-122. |
| [9] | Wei Jianing, Hao Hao, Chang Qutong, Lin Tao, Zhang Hu. Uniform Experimental Design of Constrained Region Based on Evolutionary Algorithm [J]. Journal of System Simulation, 2021, 33(7): 1591-1599. |
| [10] | Wang Kun, Ji Yao, Liu Peilun, Wang Li. Infrared Image Segmentation of Aircraft Skin Based on Otsu and Improved I-Ching Divination Evolutionary Algorithm [J]. Journal of System Simulation, 2021, 33(2): 421-433. |
| [11] | Wang Hongfeng, Zhang Yitian, Chen Jingze. An Evolutionary Multi-Objective Simulation Optimization Algorithm for Supply Chain with Uncertain Demands [J]. Journal of System Simulation, 2021, 33(12): 2761-2770. |
| [12] | Tian Hongjun, Wang Lei, Wu Qidi. MOEA/D Algorithm Based on the Hybrid Framework for Multi-objective Evolutionary Algorithm [J]. Journal of System Simulation, 2020, 32(2): 201-216. |
| [13] | Li Rongyu, Liang Dong, Qi Guihong. Adaptive Feedback Elitist Teaching-Learning-Based Optimization Algorithm [J]. Journal of System Simulation, 2018, 30(8): 2950-2957. |
| [14] | Li Linying, Lu Rui, Li Shaohua, Jing Yu, Diao Jianhua. Online Scheduling Method of Cluster Tools with Residency Time Constraint [J]. Journal of System Simulation, 2017, 29(2): 337-345. |
| Viewed | ||||||
|
Full text |
|
|||||
|
Abstract |
|
|||||